Followup: Was Linux Worth It?

January 4th, 2008 by Shawn Powers

A few days back, I posted a story regarding our LTSP server upgrades over Christmas Break here at my school district. I must confess, things didn't go well on Thursday when school resumed. In fact, it was a horrible mess. Here's the skinny:

1) Both thin client servers worked GREAT when I was the only person logging in. Once all 250ish thin clients were in use, however, things quickly fell apart. SLOW access, Firefox wouldn't load, thin clients would hang...

2) The same hardware running older versions of K12LTSP worked quite well before the upgrade, so I was pretty sure I just needed to tweak things.

3) I had no idea what to tweak.

That's where technical support comes into play. No, I don't mean I called technical support, I mean that I used the amazing community of Linux users that are willing to bend over backwards to help each other. A handful of instant messages, a couple emails to the K12LTSP listserv, and I had some quick, insightful suggestions to fix the mess.

I made a few changes based on the feedback I received, and I tweaked the few things that I was sure wouldn't hurt. This morning, things are fast and smooth. That doesn't make yesterday any better, but they say what doesn't kill you makes you stronger, and my Geek Fu is rather strong today. :)

Oh, the things I tweaked? Sure, here ya go:

1) NFS on my file server was set at the default 8 daemons. I upped that to 16, and also changed the memory allowances. I used this tutorial that Google scrounged up for me.

2) I updated Firefox to the latest stable version. The K12LTSP version I used only has 1.5, and I thought it wouldn't hurt to get version 2 running.

3) I removed the big, beautiful photos that I had for the background on the KDM login screen.

Honestly, I think that #1 was the tweak that was the "Magic Bullet" -- but the others have proven nice as well. Firefox 2 is an awesome program, and really, the background took a long time to load when it was a big photograph.

Lastly, what did all the tech support cost me? A thank you. That's it. Even that wasn't required, but it seemed the least I could do. Also, now when someone else posts a question to me either via email, instant messenger, or on a mailing list, I'll share my experience with them. For free. Honestly, although the Linux software itself is awesome, it's really the people that make open source solutions so incredible.

The really cool part? It's not just awesome geeky gurus that make the open source community so incredible. It's you. It's me. It's the student that first showed me how to drag a window by holding down the ALT key if the screen is too small. It's people that aren't afraid of looking dumb by asking questions.

Don't hesitate asking questions to mailing lists, in the forums here, or even to me personally via email. Even if we can't help each other, someone, somewhere knows somebody that can. That's why open source is so great, the community of people that make it.

So, as I'm sure you guessed, yes Linux is definitely worth it. I'm going to go bask in my new thin client goodness now, and figure out why the OSX computers in the district are logging in so slow... Ugh.
__________________________
Shawn Powers is the Associate Editor for Linux Journal. You might find him chatting on the IRC channel.


Special Magazine Offer -- 2 Free Trial Issues!
Receive 2 free trial issues of Linux Journal as well as instant online access to current and past issues. There's NO RISK and NO OBLIGATION to buy. CLICK HERE for offer

Linux Journal: delivering readers the advice and inspiration they need to get the most out of their Linux systems since 1994.

Sorry, offer available in the US only. International orders, click here.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

You can turn those Macs into LTSP thin clients

On January 4th, 2008 Terrell Prude' Jr. (not verified) says:

Hi Shawn,

Good to see your follow-up here. Turns out that Power Macs make great LTSP thin clients. K12LTSP is set up by default for this (Chuck Liebow in the Northeast has been doing this for years). I've got an orange iMac that works great as a thin client. I've even got a truly ancient Power Mac 5260 that works as a LTSP thin client (640x480x256, but the fact that it works at all, and is actually useable, amazed me!).

Oh, and if you want to get really "l33t", I've even done a lab of Sun Ultra 5's as thin clients. No sound at this point, but in a classroom full of kids, that can be a really good thing.

--TP

NX Client for Max OSX

On January 8th, 2008 Jeff Kalberg (not verified) says:

Another possibility for using Macs with any Linux terminal server is NoMachines NX Client for Mac OSX. Beyond making high-performance X connections, you have support for things like higher screen resolutions, true color, seamless windows, clipboard, shadowing, and more. You can download the NX Client for Mac OSX at http://www.nomachine.com/download-client-macosx.php

Oh, for sure!

On January 4th, 2008 Shawn Powers says:

Yeah, it was my old Powermac 5500s that coined the phrase, "Chubby Clients" -- my sole contribution to the K12LTSP efforts. :)

I've actually retired all the 5500s now, but we have probably 50 iMacs running as thin clients. They are GREAT because of the all in one-ness of them.

I guess I should have mentioned that about 20% of my thin clients are really netbooting iMacs. That would have beefed up my geek cred a bit. :)

Thanks for stopping by!
-Shawn

__________________________

Shawn Powers is the Associate Editor for Linux Journal. You might find him chatting on the IRC channel.

Featured Videos

Non-linear video editing tools are great, but they're not always the best tool for the job. This is where a powerful tool like ffmpeg becomes useful. This tutorial by Elliot Isaacson covers the basics of transcoding video, as well as more advanced tricks like creating animations, screen captures, and slow motion effects.

Shawn Powers reviews the HP Mini-Note portable computer.

Thanks to our sponsor: Silicon Mechanics

Silicon Mechanics is a leading manufacturer of rackmount servers, storage, and high performance computing hardware. The best warranty offerings available are backed by experts dedicated to customer satisfaction.

From the Magazine

August 2008, #172

There's nuttin like a Cool Project to give you some relief from the summer heat, so get out your parka cuz we got a bunch of em. First up is the BUG, not a bug, The BUG. It's got a GPS, camera and more, in a hand-sized package that's user programmable. The BUG does everything. It's both a floor wax and a dessert topping. Get one now. Need a software version of a Swiss Army knife? Take a look at Billix, and don't leave home without it. Then, chew on this one, an X server on a Gumstix device driving an E-Ink display. Need more storage? How about 16 Terabytes? Can do.

And, of course, we have the usual cast of characters: Marcel, Reuven, Dave, Kyle, Doc, plus the new kid on the block Shawn Powers. But it doesn't stop there: build a MythTV box on a budget, build your own GIS system, set up the tools to monitor your enterprise and more. Finally, remember The War of the Worlds? Now you can play too.

Read this issue