Who are the Open Source All-Stars?
July 16th, 2008 by David Lane
As I watched the opening of last night’s All-Star Game, I could not help but think of an article I read several days before where the inventor of DNS, a man named Paul Mockapetris, was telling us how serious we should be taking the DNS security issue that had been announced.
Paul who? Well, that was my response. Sure, I knew someone or a group of someones had invented DNS, but I had never heard of Paul Mockapetris before. And sitting watching last night’s All- Stars, I was struck by how many of them I had never heard of either, many of them the current players. Sure, I could tell you why Cal Ripken was standing there but I had never heard of Luis Aparicio.
Similarly, I know who Paul Vixie (BIND) is, but I had never heard of Mark Fedor (SNMP) until I worked for him. Larry Wall (Perl and others) is almost a household name, but how about Eric Allman (sendmail)?
So it got me thinking. Who are some of the All-Stars of the Open Source world? Who are the real giants? I do not think that anyone would argue about including Linus Torvalds, but what about our friend Paul Mockapetris, or is his involvement overshadowed, as one commentator said, by the efforts of Paul Vixie, who actually implemented the solution. Does Vint Cerf belong on the list? DARPA? Dennis Ritchie? Yukihiro "Matz" Matsumoto?
Let me know your thoughts and I will compile the list and then we can turn it loose to the voters. Who are the All-Stars of Open Source? Both yesterday and today.
__________________________
David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Special Magazine Offer -- Free Gift with Subscription
Receive a free digital copy of Linux Journal's System Administration Special Edition as well as instant online access to current and past issues. CLICK HERE for offer
Linux Journal: delivering readers the advice and inspiration they need to get the most out of their Linux systems since 1994.
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Facebook
Post to TwitterSubscribe now!
The Latest
Newsletter
Tech Tip Videos
Recently Popular
From the Magazine
July 2009, #183
News Flash: Linux Kernel 3.0 to include an on-the-go Expresso machine interface! Ok, maybe not, but Linux is definitely going mobile, from phones to e-readers. Find out more inside about Android, the Kindle 2, the Western Digital MyBook II, The Bug, and Indamixx (a portable recording studio). And if you've gone mobile and you been wanting more Emacs in your life then check out Conkeror.
To compliment the mobile we've got the stationary: parsing command line options with getopt, checking your Ruby code with metric_fu, and building a secure Squid proxy. How is this stationary you ask? What can we say? It's not. We just wanted to see if anybody actually read this part of the page :) .
All this and more, and all you have to do is get your hot sweaty hands on the latest copy of Linux Journal.
what about. . . .
On July 20th, 2008 proponent (not verified) says:
wow, this list is ridiculously short. It needs to include not only the great programmers but also the greatest friends of open source (and not just gpl)
- i'll agree with everyones choice of stallman. there from the start.
- how about zimmerman (PGP)? the first man to take on the U.S. and win
- his (zimmerman's) attorney (and gpl3 author) eben moglen
- tridge (also mentioned) is a wildly obvious choice
- linus - he totally belongs. if you include the gpl (esp v2) as part of open source you have to count linus. He is one of the strongest supporters of the value of open source and gplv2
- de Icaza his work on 'MS' technologies has been invaluable to the open source community
- de Raadt. Very coarse personality and views, but a staunch support of open source
- andrew morton
- alan cox
- jeremy allison
- terpstra
- ibm
Mark Fedor
On July 17th, 2008 stephen white (not verified) says:
You work for the SNMP guy? Tell him I have a foot that wants to be put in his arse, and that it belongs to the leg of a large scale admin.
On the other hand, the stuff that he must have been smoking would be truly off this planet, so I wouldn't want to harsh his buzz, man.
Worked
On July 17th, 2008 David Lane says:
Past tense, and SNMP is now in version 3 and he hasn't had his hand on it since v1. And interesting guy.
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
All-Stars?
On July 16th, 2008 JonathanH (not verified) says:
I'd second Torvalds, Matz, and Cerf...and would add John "Maddog" Hall, Guido Van Rossum, Mark Shuttleworth, Ian whassisname from Debian, Bob Young.
my honorable mentions would include Woz, Randall Schwartz, Bill Joy, Stallman (even tho' he'd hate to be on this list).
my three cents and 12 names.
Bill Joy too may hate to be on this List
On July 18th, 2008 anoop (not verified) says:
Bill Joy too might hate to be on this list. Below is a small piece of an interesting quote from an article I read from salon.com.
Intriguingly, Joy doesn't subscribe to the fundamental credo of the Linux movement -- the belief that the strength of open-source software is its ability to tap the energy and enthusiasm of a vast network of volunteer programmers. Linux is built on an egalitarian ethic: Perhaps not every programmer will write great code, but together, all those eyeballs and all those keyboard-pounding fingers will incrementally make their way toward greatness.
But Joy doesn't believe that having more programmers equals better code.
"Most people are bad programmers," says Joy. "The honest truth is that having a lot of people staring at the code does not find the really nasty bugs. The really nasty bugs are found by a couple of really smart people who just kill themselves. Most people looking at the code won't see anything ... You can't have thousands of people contributing and achieve a high standard."
The full chapter of the article can be read from the link below.
http://archive.salon.com/tech/fsp/2000/05/16/chapter_2_part_one/index2.html
All good
On July 17th, 2008 David Lane says:
Certainly all those names occurred to me as well. Randall was my introduction to Perl (as he was for most people) as well as what not to do when doing security audits. I would include in that vein Garfinkle and Spafford - visionaries both.
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Parochial Australian
On July 16th, 2008 Ritch (not verified) says:
I call for Andrew Tridgell to make the list if not because he's an Aussie then for his great marketing plan.
Before the days of GNU licenses, businesses insisting on paying for samba could contact pizza joints in his home town.
Where would we be with out him?
On July 17th, 2008 David Lane says:
Certainly Andrew has earned consideration. Samba is a major addition to the fold.
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Of course you should include
On July 16th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:
Of course you should include Stallman in the very first place!!! GNU/Linux wouldn't even exist as an idea if it wasn't for him. Torvalds... oh well, he is a hell of a good programmer, but not an OpenSource fighter at all... I'd include him in Programming All Stars, not in Free Software All Stars ;)
Who said anything about Free
On July 16th, 2008 theillien says:
Who said anything about Free Software All-Stars? The article is about Open Source All-Stars.
I would argue that Marc Andreesen belongs in the group. While Mosaic itself wasn't open source it led to Mozilla and ultimately Firefox.
Also a good point
On July 16th, 2008 David Lane says:
I certainly did not. And I would agree that Marc is a worthy candidate.
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Of course!
On July 16th, 2008 David Lane says:
Now how could I forget Richard Stallman. I had his quote on my door for years..."Free as in Free Speech, not free beer."
I agree that Linus is a controversial figure. Much like Pete Rose. Your mileage will vary. (Let's not have a Pete Rose fight here - but if you want to discuss Linus's value, go for it.)
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Te guy who started it all,
On July 16th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:
Te guy who started it all, and found the money to fund it. Virtually all of the projects that led to the development of personal computing and the internet were his projects:
"Joseph Carl Robnett Licklider (March 11, 1915 – June 26, 1990), known simply as J.C.R. or "Lick" was an American computer scientist, considered one of the most important figures in computer science and general computing history."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J.C.R._Licklider
News to me
On July 17th, 2008 David Lane says:
Sounds like someone to consider then. I have never heard of him, but then, that does not make his contributions any less valid.
__________________________David Lane is a member of Linux Journal's Reader Advisory Board.
Post new comment