What's in the Water at OLPC?

May 19th, 2008 by Justin Ryan

The One Laptop Per Child program has been in a steadily increasing tailspin over the past few months, from dumping multi-billion dollar sponsors to driving away key staff. Now it appears the whole project is about three steps away from the handbasket.

The latest developments in the OLPC saga have Walter Bender, former man-in-charge and now leader-in-exile forking his own group to manage development of the OLPC's open-source educational interface Sugar. Bender claims that OLPC has given up on pushing education, and is instead interested only in the number of laptops that can be shipped out — an area in which the OLPC has a rather poor record. Bender's project — christened Sugar Labs — will focus on providing educational software to children, and will make it available to a variety of platforms — though Windows, which will now run the majority of the OLPC's XO laptops, "isn't a priority."

Another recent departure from the OLPC, former security chief Ivan Krstíc, has also been sharing his thoughts on the program, albeit somewhat differently than Mr. Bender. According to reports, in his latest blog post on the project, Krstíc lashes out at nearly everyone involved, from the project itself, to it's vendors, and even the open-source community. At one point he seems to oppose Windows on the XO, saying the project shouldn't be about "economic incentives for a particular vendor," but then comes back to attack the XO's open-source contributors, declaring that children would "prefer the damn software works and doesn't need fixing." The post is rounded off by an inspiring and uplifting call to arms, proclaiming that everyone should "put our idiotic trifles aside, end our endless yapping, and get to it already."

Sadly, with the way things are going, the only "it" the project seems likely to get to is a spectacular implosion.

__________________________
Justin Ryan is News Editor for LinuxJournal.com.
Visit Linux Journal on IRC.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Too Bad

On May 19th, 2008 Aaron Poffenberger (not verified) says:

I really like the XO. We bought one for each of our children during the G1G1 program. Since it's mostly an open platform and we have the source for the XO-1 I'm not worried about it. I really hope OLPC at least keep Linux a serious option (of course they claim they will but OLPC credibility is at a low right now).

I'm encouraged, though, by Walter Bender's continued commitment to the software platform. Whether the OLPC finds its direction or not, Sugar may yet live on. Our favorite activity on the XOs are the shared web browsing. My children love group browsing and sharing the various photos and pages they find on the net when they're interested in a subject.

Featured Video

Shawn Powers has a message for hardware vendors. Listen up!

From the Magazine

August 2008, #172

There's nuttin like a Cool Project to give you some relief from the summer heat, so get out your parka cuz we got a bunch of em. First up is the BUG, not a bug, The BUG. It's got a GPS, camera and more, in a hand-sized package that's user programmable. The BUG does everything. It's both a floor wax and a dessert topping. Get one now. Need a software version of a Swiss Army knife? Take a look at Billix, and don't leave home without it. Then, chew on this one, an X server on a Gumstix device driving an E-Ink display. Need more storage? How about 16 Terabytes? Can do.

And, of course, we have the usual cast of characters: Marcel, Reuven, Dave, Kyle, Doc, plus the new kid on the block Shawn Powers. But it doesn't stop there: build a MythTV box on a budget, build your own GIS system, set up the tools to monitor your enterprise and more. Finally, remember The War of the Worlds? Now you can play too.

Read this issue