Contradictions in Microsoft's OOXML openness
January 18th, 2007 by Nicholas Petreley
There is a fascinating article on Groklaw called Searching for Openness in Microsoft's OOXML and Finding Contradictions. One of the most relevant comments in the article is "So, they plan to be the only one in the Linux world that can actually interoperate with Microsoft. How do you think they will achieve that? By sharing? On the contrary, they already market themselves as uniquely interoperable, which means they get to interoperate and you don't, unless you are their paying customer." There is also the Novell comment, "Only Novell has Microsoft’s endorsement as its partner to drive Linux-Windows interoperability."
The article aptly mentions that Microsoft is still in court over the allegation that it is deliberately withholding API information from competitors in defiance of the 2002 judgment. The point here is that Microsoft cannot be trusted as a partner or competitor. This adds fuel to the controversy over whether or not the Microsoft-Novell deal is a good thing for anyone but Microsoft.
Having said that, the more important reading material is the article, The Contradictory Nature of OOXML. It explores the holes, the vendor-dependencies, and other contradictions in the "openness" of OOXML.
While I think the Groklaw article is worth reading, I believe the exclusivity Novell has in this deal is a red herring. It's bad, but it's not the real problem. Bob Sutor put his finger on the real problem in this article where he appropriately suggests that Microsoft isn't interested in interoperability, but is interested in intraoperability, which is quite different.
Bob says, "when the software provider comes out and says “we just created a consortium to provide interoperability with our products,
__________________________
Subscribe now!
Recently Popular
| How Should Mozilla Execute Its Vision? | Jul-08-08 |
| Why Python? | May-01-00 |
| Building a Call Center with LTSP and Soft Phones | Aug-25-05 |
| An Open Video to HP | Jul-02-08 |
| Add an Auto-Incrementing Build-Number to Your Build Process | Jul-08-08 |
| Automating the creation of slide shows in OpenOffice.org | Jul-07-08 |
Featured Video
From the Magazine
August 2008, #172
There's nuttin like a Cool Project to give you some relief from the summer heat, so get out your parka cuz we got a bunch of em. First up is the BUG, not a bug, The BUG. It's got a GPS, camera and more, in a hand-sized package that's user programmable. The BUG does everything. It's both a floor wax and a dessert topping. Get one now. Need a software version of a Swiss Army knife? Take a look at Billix, and don't leave home without it. Then, chew on this one, an X server on a Gumstix device driving an E-Ink display. Need more storage? How about 16 Terabytes? Can do.
And, of course, we have the usual cast of characters: Marcel, Reuven, Dave, Kyle, Doc, plus the new kid on the block Shawn Powers. But it doesn't stop there: build a MythTV box on a budget, build your own GIS system, set up the tools to monitor your enterprise and more. Finally, remember The War of the Worlds? Now you can play too.
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Technorati






We think this is an
On September 30th, 2007 Home Refurbish Course (not verified) says:
We think this is an inspiring article.
stop ooxml
On September 3rd, 2007 новини (not verified) says:
stop ooxml, stop microsoft, stop IE!
If you cant't beat them
On June 21st, 2007 Rainer (not verified) says:
It's the old common thing:
If you can't beat them - buy them ... MS extension now: If you can't beat or buy them - join them.
And what will happen then? Can you remember the Trojan horse?
Maybe this is why Linux doesnt own the Desktop…
On June 10th, 2007 tutoriale php (not verified) says:
As soon as someone tries to fast-track development and try to get Linux working with the biggest IT-monopoly it will be defamed and deriled for a sellout. Please step out of the way of advancement and let Linux flourish.
me don't trust ms
On January 27th, 2007 linux microsoft (not verified) says:
me, like lots of linux users don't like ms much, there would be lots more useful software, if ms did not have such a large market share, ms is no good for open source
linux
On October 2nd, 2007 enigma downloader (not verified) says:
do a library? make shared I How Thanks.
The Contradictory Nature of OOXML
On January 19th, 2007 Anonymous (not verified) says:
Where is the The Contradictory Nature of OOXML??
I did'nt find it.