Beware What is Hiding in Your Laptop – And Who Wants to Look at It
October 6th, 2008 by Justin Ryan
As many readers will likely know, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security — for whom we're sure we could find many a fitting and unflattering nickname, if it wouldn't land us a all-expenses-paid visit to Gitmo — recently released guidelines for the U.S. Customs Service giving agents carte blanche to search and seize travelers' laptops without probable cause, including U.S. citizens, who once upon a time were protected from such things by the Fourth Amendment. After much — well-deserved — outrage, someone is finally doing something about it, in the persons of Senators Russ Feingold & Maria Cantwell, who introduced legislation last week to put the brakes on DHS's searchmobile.
Under rules published in July, any laptop crossing the U.S. border is subject to being searched, copied, and indefinitely detained without any reason whatsoever — much as though they've all been classified "enemy computants." The move, as might be expected, has been denounced by civil liberties groups and individuals of sound mind across the country, and indeed in the international community, as defying the basic principles of liberty which the U.S. has historically embraced. The federal courts, who are generally responsible for protecting citizens from this sort of thing, have ruled in favor of the searches — proving once again that vision insurance for federal judges should be a national priority.
All that may be put to a stop sometime next year, however, as the bill introduced by Senators Feingold & Cantwell — the Travelers' Privacy Protection Act — would return the status quo that has served perfectly well for 217 years. Customs agents would once again be required to have probable cause in order to search an individual's computer, and would be required to obtain a court order to detain one for longer than 24 hours. Due to the short Congressional term remaining, the bill — or the identical one introduced in the House by Representative Adam Smith — will likely not see action until the 2009 session, however, its introduction underscores the outrage felt by citizens nation-wide. It has, predictably, had little effect on DHS, with (outgoing) Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff issuing hysterical predictions of lawsuits and Congressional regulations tying the hands of brave Customs agents and leading to an inevitable attack by terrorists.
Because we all know, Osama Bin Laden is hiding in Aunt Bessie from Boise's laptop, right next to the pictures of Cousin Jimmy's piano recital and her secret recipe for Pepto-Bismol pumpkin pie.
__________________________
Justin Ryan is News Editor for LinuxJournal.com.
Submit a tip: Email IRC
Special Magazine Offer -- 2 Free Trial Issues!
Receive 2 free trial issues of Linux Journal as well as instant online access to current and past issues. There's NO RISK and NO OBLIGATION to buy. CLICK HERE for offer
Linux Journal: delivering readers the advice and inspiration they need to get the most out of their Linux systems since 1994.
Sorry, offer available in the US only. International orders, click here.
Subscribe now!
The Latest
Featured Videos
Linux Journal Live - eBook Readers and DRM
November 14th, 2008 by Shawn Powers in
The November 13, 2008 edition of Linux Journal Live! Shawn Powers and special guest, Linux Journal Author Daniel Bartholomew, talk e-book readers and Daniel's Kindle, DRM, and other goodness.
Run Your Windows Partition Without Rebooting
November 13th, 2008 by Elliot Isaacson in
Dual booting is a necessary evil and very inconvenient. What if you could run your windows partition in a virtual machine, so you wouldn't have to worry about rebooting anymore? With VMWare Workstation, you can.
Recently Popular
From the Magazine
December 2008, #176
The Oxford English Dictionary says the word "gadget" is a placeholder name for a technical item whose precise name one can't remember. Like that book-reader thingy from Amazon...what's it called? Spindle, Gindle...Kindle, that's it. Check it out in this month's gadget issue.
Other gadgets covered include the Nokia tablets, the BlackBerry, the Neo FreeRunner, the Dash Express, the Roku Netflix Player, the Kangaroo TV, The TomTom GO 930 and the MooBella Ice Cream System. On the larger hardware front, read the reviews of the Acer Aspire One and the YDL PowerStation. On the software front, check out the articles and columns on memcached, Samba security, Mutt, desktop gadgets, bash and Puppet. To wrap it all up, read Doc's thoughts on Google and the browser platform.
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Technorati







Vote Ron Paul
On October 8th, 2008 Darko (not verified) says:
All this is perfectly explained by Republican candidate Ron Paul.
If there is still any sense in USA citizens, vote Ron Paul (now it might be late, but next time it wont be).
Two books worth reading
On October 7th, 2008 barryp says:
Two books that I'd recommend everyone (not just US citizens) read are:
"The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism" by Naomi Klein, here.
and
"The Assault on Reason" by Al Gore, here.
As the last poster states, this may not be a topic for the LJ site, but we all carry a lot of personal (private) stuff on our laptops, so the advice of the article is applicable. What amazes me is how many "freedoms" the American people are willing to give up (with next to no public debate on whether or not giving up said freedoms is a good idea), as well as the type of things they are willing to impose on others. As an example, for me to travel to the US from Ireland, I have to provide up to 30 pieces of "personal data" so that the US authorities can convince themselves that I'm not a terrorist. When I arrive Stateside, I'm required to be finger-printed! My own government (which is obviously "friendly" toward to USA) does not require American citizens to be finger-printed upon entry into our country ... and I would imagine there would be quite an outcry from the American visitors to our country if we did. In fact, my own government wouldn't dare ask for my finger-prints unless it was part of some ongoing criminal investigation and I was a suspect. But the US government thinks it is their right to finger-print every visitor to their shores ... no finger-prints, no entry. Not exactly welcoming, is it?
Within the GNU/Linux community, we are well used to spotting and dealing effectively with FUD when we come across it. It is a pity that the US government uses FUD on a global scale to hurt the US's reputation as one of the most welcoming nations of the last 200 years or so.
__________________________Paul Barry
More reading matter
On October 7th, 2008 Segodnya (not verified) says:
I'd also recommend anything by James Bovard, but most particularly "Lost Rights." In addition, if you have not read "The Puzzle Palace," by James Bamford, please take a look. There is a sequel, and a soon-to-be-released second sequel. Both expose the NSA's long involvement in domestic spying (it ain't just the Bush Administration, folks)(but I don't care; it's still illegal), the illegal cooperation of telecommunications companies and their long-standing fear that they would be prosecuted for it, etc. It's an absolutely hair-raising story.
Some readers might find the occasional dabbling in politics on this site rather off-putting, but I myself do not as long as we remain focused mostly on Linux. We need to remember, however, that Linux is partly an outgrowth of a certain disdain for big institutions: big government, big corporations, etc., combined with a love for open source programming. It is sometimes not possible to fully separate Linux from the society in which Linux is produced and consumed.
One last comment and then I'll shut my trap: just "getting over it" will not do. As long as we're going to proclaim by bullhorn from the rooftops that we're the greatest country on Earth, then by God we need to stop infringing on the civil rights of our own citizenry and throwing our weight around overseas like a giant bully just because we can. Our country has lost its way, and undermines the very principles for which we used to be admired and which made our society great. You are, of course, free to disagree with me . . . and I am, of course, free to maintain and re-state this deeply held belief until hell freezes. And as long as Linux helps me be a little more free of the tyranny of those big institutions, I will continue to support it.
Great site, by the way, and long live Linux.
Not about criticism... it's about stupid, exaggerated criticism
On October 9th, 2008 TexasTwister (not verified) says:
My "get over it" comment was not to suggest that criticism of government policies was out of bounds -- even on a site where that is not the intended purpose. But that such back-handed, baseless, unfounded and untrue slaps accomplish nothing and should be out of bounds for any self-respecting editor.
You want to argue that the current guidelines are inappropriate, even unconstitutional? Or that the proposed bill is a good thing? I'll GLADLY hear your reasoned explanation and arguments. And frankly, I probably agree in this case. But the first and last sentences of the article (along with other parenthetical thoughts throughout it) are baseless and inflammatory -- and they lower my expectation that I'll find any reasoned explanation and argument in an article written by someone who feels the need to "spice up" their prose with such nonsense.
Educate me or persuade me -- don't try to inflame me with raw-meat rhetoric.
Stupid, exaggerated "security" measures
On October 10th, 2008 El Perro Loco (not verified) says:
The "security measures" that allow for the government to *steal* people's property and information and to trample over people's rights and freedom, *that* is what is stupid and exaggerated, not the reaction to it!
I feel sorry for the
On October 6th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:
I feel sorry for the american goverment and its people. And you guys ask your selfs why the world hates you. This is one of the reasons. You all brag about your freedom and all that crap. You have as much freedom as north koreans have. What the fuck happened to the biggest country in the world. You were ones a nations other nations looked up to. Now you have a paranoid goverment. Who has done more wrong than right.
Vote Obama. A man that will give you people change. Not the same crap over and over again.
Peace out!
Oh Get over it!
On October 6th, 2008 Texas Twister (not verified) says:
How absurd! Give me the name of ONE person... just one!... who was imprisoned for "unflattering nicknames" for Homeland Security or any other US Department or government official!
Of course you have to the freedom to backhandedly slam the current administration -- or openly if you so chose (despite your ludicrous protestations to the contrary) in a publication purportedly about Linux and not politics. But I also have the freedom to seek my Linux news from sites that don't try to mingle it with dubious political commentary.
Strip the sarcasm, report the facts and I'm with you. Go further down this path and you've lost a regular reader.
Post new comment