Internet Radio to Podcast with Shell Tools
July 28th, 2005 by Phil Salkie in
It all started because I wanted to listen to “Hour of the Wolf” on WBAI radio—it's a cool science-fiction radio program hosted by Jim Freund that features readings, music, author interviews and good “I was there when...” kind of stories. Unfortunately for me, WBAI broadcasts from Long Island, New York, and is too far away from me to receive well. Plus, the show is on Saturday mornings from 5 to 7AM EST—not a really welcoming timeslot for us working folks.
Then, I discovered that WBAI has streaming MP3 audio on its Web site, which solved the reception problem. That left the Oh-Dark-Hundred problem—I'm normally settling into a deep sleep at that hour. And science-fiction buff or no, I'm not going to be catching Jim live any time soon.
What I needed was a VCR for Internet radio. Specifically, I wanted to capture the stream and save it to disk as an MP3 file, named with the show name and date. I would need to add the proper MP3 ID tags so I could load it into my Neuros audio player for convenient listening. It also would be awfully nice if I could let RSS-compatible software know that I've captured these files. That way, they would show up in a Firefox live bookmark or could be transferred to an iPod during charging. The ultimate effect would be to create an automatic podcast—a dynamically updated RSS feed with links to saved recordings—by snipping a single show out of an Internet media stream at regular intervals.
So, off I went to Google to search for “mp3 stream recording” and “tivo radio” and so on. I found many packages and Web sites, but nothing seemed quite right. Then, I heard a voice from my past—that of the great Master Foo in Eric S. Raymond's “The Rootless Root”, which said to me: “There is more UNIX-nature in one line of shell script than there is in ten thousand lines of C.” So, I wondered if I could accomplish the task using the tools already on the system, connected by a simple shell script.
You see, I already could play the stream by using the excellent MPlayer media player software. Due to patent problems, Fedora Core 3 doesn't ship with MP3 support, so I previously had downloaded and built MPlayer from source as part of the process of MP3-enabling my system. On a side note, MPlayer makes extensive use of the specific hardware features of each different CPU type, so it performs much better as a video player if it is built from source on the machine where you plan to use it. The command:
mplayer -cache 128 \ -playlist http://www.2600.com/wbai/wbai.m3u
served admirably to play the stream through my speakers. All that was left to do was convince MPlayer to save to disk instead. The MPlayer man page revealed -dumpaudio and -dumpfile <filename>, which work together to read the stream and silently save it out to disk, forever and ever. There's no time-out, so it captures until you kill the MPlayer process. Therefore, I wrote this script:
#!/bin/bash mplayer -cache 128 \ -playlist http://www.2600.com/wbai/wbai.m3u \ -dumpaudio -dumpfile test.mp3 & # the & sets the job running in the background sleep 30s kill $! # kill the most recently backgrounded job
which nicely captured a 30-or-so-second MP3 file to disk. The & character at the end of the mplayer command above is critical; it makes MPlayer run as a background task, so the shell script can continue past it to the next command, a timed sleep. Once the sleep is done, the script then kills the last backgrounded task, ending the recording. You may need to adjust the -cache value to suit your Internet connection or even substitute -nocache.
Now that part one was accomplished, I was on to part two—inserting the MP3 ID tags. Back on Google, I found id3v2, a handy little command-line program that adds tags to an MP3 file—and it's already in the Fedora Core distribution! It's amazing, the things that are lurking on your hard drive.
I now had the tools in place to capture and tag my favorite shows. With that in place, I was left with the task of coming up with some way to make a syndication feed from the stack of files. It turns out that RSS feeds are simple eXtensible Markup Language (XML) files that contain links to the actual data we want to feed, whether that be a Web page or, as in this case, an MP3 file.
Another quick look at Google brought me to the XML::RSS module for Perl. It's a complete set of tools that both can create new RSS files and add entries to existing ones. At this point, I thought I was almost done and put together a nice code example that almost worked. In true project timeline tradition, however, the last 5% of the project turned out to require 95% of the total time.
Once I had a script that did all I wanted it to do, I sent it in to LJ along with a first version of this article. LJ Editor in Chief Don Marti pointed out that I was missing one key component: my program was generating an RSS version 1.0 feed, but all the podcast-aware programs look for a version 2.0 feed—specifically for an XML tag named enclosure. Naturally, I assumed it would be a trivial change to my software, merely switching versions and adding the enclosure tag. I soon learned, however, that the XML::RSS Perl module can write RSS 2.0 but cannot read it. Several sleepless nights ensued, until I determined that Perl tools were available that could read RSS 2.0 but not write it. So, it was time to add some glue.
I started by adding two Perl modules to my system—you can install them (as root) with:
perl -e "install XML::RSS,XML::Simple" -MCPAN
You probably will be okay with answering any questions it asks with the default. If you haven't used the Comprehensive Perl Archive Network (CPAN) yet, it asks quite a few setup questions, such as choosing several mirror sites that are close to you. Otherwise, it simply asks about a dependency or two; say yes.
After the two modules and their required dependencies are installed, you need to create a new XML file with information about the show you want to capture. The great thing about XML is you can use any text editor to make a file that is readable by both humans and machines, making it easy to create, view, test and modify RSS feed files. Let's start with this skeleton, containing a basic title section:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <rss version="2.0"> <channel> <title>Hour of the Wolf</title> <link>http://www.hourwolf.com</link> <description>Science Fiction Talk Radio with Jim Freund</description> <generator>WBAI Stream Capture using Linux shell tools</generator> </channel> </rss>
If you never have played with XML before, this is a good time to get your feet wet. A quick look at the file shows data items surrounded by HTML-like tags, where each <something> tag has a corresponding </something> to close the something section. This becomes more confusing later, though, when we add the alternate syntax, which looks like <tagname a=“A” b=“B” />.
Once I had gathered all the tools I needed, I added a few droplets of shell magic to arrive at this simple script:
#!/bin/bash
# catchthewolf - capture "Hour of the Wolf"
# For capturing the stream
DATE=`date +%F` # Save the date as YYYY-MM-DD
YEAR=`date +%Y` # Save just the year as YYYY
FILE=/home/phil/wolf.$DATE.mp3 # Where to save it
STREAM=http://www.2600.com/wbai/wbai.m3u
DURATION=2.1h # enough to catch the show, plus a bit
#DURATION=30s # a quick run, just for testing
# For the RSS syndication
XML="/home/phil/wolfrss.xml" # file for the RSS feed
ITEMS=15 # Maximum items in RSS list
XTITLE="Hour of the Wolf - $DATE Broadcast"
XDATE=`date -R` # Date in RFC 822 format for RSS
i=\$i;o=\$o;m=\$m # replace "$" in the perl script
# For the id3v2 Tags
AUTHOR="Jim Freund"
ALBUM="WBAI Stream Rip"
TITLE="Hour of the Wolf - $DATE"
# Use mplayer to capture the stream
# at $STREAM to the file $FILE
/usr/local/bin/mplayer -really-quiet -cache 128 \
-dumpfile $FILE -dumpaudio -playlist $STREAM &
# the & turns the capture into a background job
sleep $DURATION # wait for the show to be over
kill $! # end the stream capture
# Tag the resulting captured .mp3
id3v2 -a "$AUTHOR" -A "$ALBUM" \
-t "$TITLE" -y $YEAR -T 1/1 -g 255 \
--TCON "Radio" $FILE
# Add a new entry in the rss file,
# keep the file to a max of $ITEMS entries,
# and change the file's date to right now.
/usr/bin/perl -e "use XML::RSS; use XML::Simple; \
$i=XMLin('$XML');$o=$i;bless $o,XML::RSS; \
$m=$i->{channel}{item};if((ref $m)ne ARRAY) \
{$o->add_item(%$m);} else \
{foreach $m (@{$m}) {$o->add_item(%$m);}} \
$o->channel(lastBuildDate=>'$XDATE', \
pubDate=>'$XDATE'); \
$o->add_item(title=>'$XTITLE', \
link=>$o->{'channel'}{'link'}, \
pubDate=>'$XDATE', \
enclosure=>{url=>'file://$FILE', \
length=>(stat('$FILE'))[7], \
type=>'audio/mpeg'}, mode=>'insert'); \
pop(@{$o->{'items'}}) \
while (@{$o->{'items'}}>$ITEMS); \
$o->{encoding}='UTF-8'; $o->save('$XML');"
echo "Caught the wolf."
This doesn't look too simple, though. Let's dissect this script a bit to see how it all works. Notice the back-ticks (`) around the date commands. They take whatever is enclosed in the `` marks and run it as a command and then replace the entire `whatevercommand` with the output from that command. If I had needed the date only once, I could have written:
FILE=wolf.`/bin/date +%F`.mp3
or even:
/usr/local/bin/mplayer -dumpaudio \ -dumpfile "wolf.`/bin/date +%F`.mp3" \
But because I wanted the date for the filename, the tag and the RSS feed, I stored it in the $DATE shell variable. That makes it much easier to change the script around too. I now have several scripts that capture streams, and the only things that have to change are the variable assignments at the top.
Back-ticks are one of the shell's tools that allow us to merge simple commands into powerful assemblies. You can play with this more by using the echo command. Try, for example:
echo "wolf.`date +%F`.mp3"
to see what the filename would be in that last call to MPlayer.
We use the +%F formatting option to date, because the default date string is full of spaces. Also, my USA locale's date string has / characters in it—not the best thing to try to put inside a filename. Furthermore, the yyyy-mm-dd format means the files sort nicely by date when you list the directory. The RSS feed wants its date in RFC 822 format, so we wind up calling /bin/date three times in all.
Notice also that I'm giving the exact path to some of the executable commands. I do this so that when the script runs as a timed task, it won't have my personal shell's path settings. If you're unsure where a file lives, find it with which:
[phil@asylumhouse]$ which date /bin/date
You're safe to leave off /bin and /usr/bin, but any other path should be specified explicitly, as should paths to any executable that exists as different versions in multiple locations.
The call to id3v2 tags the file as track 1 of 1, with proper author, album, title and year entries. The predefined genre number of 255 means Other. The --TCON entry fills in Radio in place of one of the predefined genres on any software that understands version 2 MP3 tags.
Lastly, the one-line Perl script at the end is a compressed version of this:
#!/usr/bin/perl
use XML::RSS; use XML::Simple;
$in=XMLin('/home/phil/wolfrss.xml');
$out=$in; # copy the parsed RSS file's tree
bless $out, XML::RSS; # make the copy an XML::RSS
# blessing doesn't copy the items. Drat!
$item = $in->{channel}{item};
if ((ref $item) ne ARRAY) { # only one item in feed
$out->add_item(%$item);
} else { # a list of items - foreach the list
foreach $item (@{$item}) {
$out->add_item(%$item);
}
}
# Encoding doesn't transfer either.
$out->{encoding}='UTF-8';
# Date the file so client software knows it changed
$date = `date -R`;
$out->channel( lastBuildDate=>'$date',
pubDate=>'$date');
# Add our newest captured file
$file = "/home/phil/wolfcaught.mp3";
$out->add_item( title => "Hour of the Wolf",
link => $out->{'channel'}{'link'},
pubDate => '$date',
enclosure => { url=>"file://$file",
length => (stat($file))[7],
type => 'audio/mpeg'
},
mode => 'insert');
# Don't have more than 15 items in the podcast
while (@{$out->{'items'}} > 15) {
pop(@{$out->{'items'}};
}
# Write out the finished file
$out->save('/home/phil/wolfrss.xml');"
Here I use XML::Simple to read and parse the existing .RSS file and XML::RSS to add our new item and write the modified version. The bless function tells Perl that the XML::Simple object $out now should be treated as an XML::RSS object. The only reason this does anything useful is the two modules use nearly identical variable names internally, derived from the tag names of the incoming RSS file.
This bless function copies over almost anything in the RSS file's header, but it doesn't bring over item or encoding tags. So I then copied over each item in a foreach loop, added today's date as the build and publication date and added the just-captured file as a new item. This item has a Web page link that is copied from the header, today's date as publication date and the all-important enclosure tag. The enclosure has a URL, in this case a file:// reference, because we are doing everything on the local filesystem. It also has a file length and a MIME type, audio/mpeg.
Shell variables replace all the quoted strings, and the super-sneaky shell variables $i, $o and $m get replaced by \$i, \$o and \$m. In other words, everywhere you see $i in the Perl script, the Perl interpreter actually gets the Perl variable name $i. Without that bit of substitution, the shell would replace each $i with a null string or, worse yet, whatever the shell variable i happened to hold before the script was executed. The reference to the actual MP3 file is a URL, file:///home/phil/wolf.2005-03-19.mp3, not merely a filename. When we enter the RSS feed file into Firefox or a feed aggregator program, we refer to it using URL notation as well, file:///home/phil/wolfrss.xml.
It may seem strange that I'm calling a scripting language from another scripting language. The point is that I'm using each to do the things it's best at. Bash is designed to execute commands, and it's really easy to start a background process, find out its process ID and kill it again. On the other hand, trying to add an XML entry in Bash using the more basic string-handling tools, such as sed and grep, would have been, well, exactly the kind of thing that drove Larry Wall to write Perl in the first place.
Now that we have a script, we make the file executable and run it:
chmod +x catchthewolf ./catchthewolf
which results in a properly tagged MP3 file and a new entry in the wolfrss.xml RSS feed. When testing, you can uncomment the 30-second test line to make sure everything's working properly, but be sure to comment it back out before trying to catch a show.
Now all that's left is to get our computer to run this thing at 5AM on Saturday. That's done by using the system's cron utility—invoke crontab -e— and adding an entry like this:
MAILTO=phil # Testing: mail script output to me # Catch hour of the wolf 5AM Saturdays 59 4 * * sat /home/phil/catchthewolf
crontab's editor is most likely to be set to vi-style commands, so you have to use i to start typing and <Esc>:wq to save-and-exit. When you're done, you should see this message:
crontab: installing new crontab
which says you're all set. Check man 5 crontab for more information on how to make jobs repeat every day, once a month or whatever. You also want to make sure your user name is in the file /etc/cron.allow—the list of who can run jobs on the system's scheduler. If you're running on a remote system, verify with the administrators that you're allowed to run cron jobs.
To see the resulting podcast, point your RSS-aware software at the XML file the script creates. In Firefox, use Bookmarks→Manage Bookmarks→Add Live Bookmark, and remember to enter the URL starting with file:// and not the filename itself.
By taking two programs already on the hard drive, downloading two Perl modules and writing a few lines of shell script, we have assembled a homebrew Webcast recording system that saves our favorite programs for us to listen to whenever we choose. It also lets us know what it has done by popping up live bookmarks in Firefox and automatically transfers the recordings to our MP3 player. Some scripts for capturing other Internet radio shows will be available on the Linux Journal FTP site (see the on-line Resources). Now I just have to remember to delete the older files before my hard drive fills up with leftover Webcasts.
Thanks to Anne Troop, Jen Hamilton and Chris Riley for their many shell-scripting hints over the years; to Anne's friend Janeen Pisciotta for finding “Hour of the Wolf” for us in the first place; and to LJ Editor in Chief Don Marti for the cool podcast idea.
Resources for this article: /article/8402.
Subscribe now!
Breaking News
| AMD Calls Out Intel...We Think. | 2 days 18 hours ago |
| Bye-Bye TorrentSpy, So Long MPAA's Money | 2 days 20 hours ago |
| Sun Finds the Keys to Unlock MySQL | 4 days 15 hours ago |
| New Powers on the Throne – or Heads on the Block – at OLPC | 5 days 14 hours ago |
Featured Video
Linux Journal Gadget Guy, Shawn Powers, takes us through installing Ubuntu on a machine running Windows with the Wubi installer.
Live From the Field
The latest posts from the Linux Journal team.
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Technorati






Internet Radio to Podcast with Shell Tools
On May 11th, 2008 sindy says:
this is a very good article
__________________________A Giyotin P Msn nickleri O Sohbet odaları
something is broken...
On October 3rd, 2007 Donovan Worrell says:
Hi, thanks for the article on this it has helped me automate some recordings I need on a daily basis. A couple of things I noticed...I included the use strict;use warnings on the script you cited and have come up with some odd errors. I have worked through most of them but cannot figure out how to "fix" this:
Unregistered entity: Can't access modules field in object of class XML::RSS at /usr/lib/perl5/site_perl/5.8.5/XML/RSS/Private/Output/Base.pm line 926
any ideas? It seems to be centered around this:
bless\$out,XML::RSS;
based on this error:
Bareword "XML::RSS" not allowed while "strict subs" in use at -e line 1.
Bareword "ARRAY" not allowed while "strict subs" in use at -e line 1.
What am I missing here?
FIXED!!!
On October 11th, 2007 Donovan Worrell says:
Hey,
Much thanks to the maintainers of XML::RSS specifically Shlomi Fish for this diff that fixes this script to work with XML::RSS current.
podcast.diff
--- podcast.sh.old 2007-10-11 20:06:41.077613900 +0200
+++ podcast.sh 2007-10-11 20:11:26.685655662 +0200
@@ -108,31 +108,19 @@
+use strict; \
+use warnings; \
use XML::RSS; \
-my \$in = XMLin('$XML'); \
-my \$out = \$in; \
-bless \$out, XML::RSS; \
-my \$item = \$in->{channel}{item}; \
-
-if ( ( ref \$item ) ne ARRAY ) { \
-
- \$out->add_item(%\$item); \
-} \
-else { \
- foreach \$item ( @{\$item} ) { \
- \$out->add_item(%\$item); \
- } \
-} \
+my \$out = XML::RSS->new(version => '2.0'); \
+\$out->parsefile('$XML'); \
\$out->channel( lastBuildDate => '$XDATE', pubDate => '$XDATE' ); \
linux
On October 2nd, 2007 enigma voyageur mp3 download (not verified) says:
How bootable a make do floppy? I . Bye.
What does this achieve?
On June 24th, 2007 TRiG (not verified) says:
I'm not enough of a geek to understand this. (I'm a trainee geek.) Nor do I yet use Linux. (I may switch over when Microsoft drops XP support. I don't like the way XP tries to organise my life for me, and I'm told Vista is worse.)
With the above code you record a predetermined section of an Internet radio station (a programme), yes? And then you produce RSS code which creates a podcast feed of that program, yes? And then, on another computer, you set up a program (iTunes or something similar) to download that podcast, yes?
Do I understand you right? On computer 1 (always on the Internet), you record the programme and produce the podcast, and then on computer 2 (and potentially many other computers) (occasionally on the internet) you subscribe to that podcast. It seems a long-winded way of going about it, but I can see some benefits.
For those of us without access to always-online computers, is there any way we can set up such podcasts? Can we, somewhere, enter the URL of a live radio station (say http://www.cbc.ca/listen/streams/r1_toronto_32.html) and some times (say 19:00-20:00 on what I think is Eastern Time), and be given a resultant podcast feed to subscribe to?
(I live in Ireland, and don't have much experience with Canadian and US time zones. If you can understand the time expressions on the Vinyl Tap page, please explain them to me.)
Re: What does this achieve?
On July 25th, 2007 Phil Salkie says:
You don't need two computers - the machine which you're saving the radio shows on makes an XML file so that podcast-aware programs can pick up the new radio shows as they're recorded, and automatically put them on to your music player at recharge/sync time. Maybe this will be an excuse to install Kubuntu on a spare hard drive partition and get your feet wet with Linux!
There's no service that I'm aware of that will make a podcast for you, basically for copyright reasons - perhaps someone in a less copyright-frenzied country will do that, and make a ton of money.
For Canadian times, look at: http://www.timetemperature.com/tzca/canada_time_zone.shtml
They seem to be assuming Eastern, AT is Atlantic, NT is Newfoundland.
For a possible way to do a similar thing on your XP machine, look at:
http://streamripper.sourceforge.net/
(You'll have to configure automatic dialing to the internet on your XP system for that to work.)
RDF, not RTF!
On November 17th, 2006 Evan Prodromou (not verified) says:
You said, "RSS stands for RTF Site Summary." Actually, it stands for "RDF Site Summary" -- the original name from the My Netscape Network. RDF is a framework for making statements about resources (like Web sites); see http://www.w3.org/RDF/ .
RTF is the "Rich Text Format", the default word processing exchange format used in WordPad and other word processors. It has nothing to do with RSS.
Re: RDF, not RTF!
On July 25th, 2007 Phil Salkie says:
You are, of course, correct. Sadly, I've been caught perpetuating one of those errors like "to gild the lily" - so many people do it that it's become almost right. So, indeed, s/RTF/RDF/G9000
use fifo as intermediate wav file
On July 20th, 2006 Henk Postma (not verified) says:
You may save a lot of intermediate disk space by using a fifo buffer for the wav file. I use this for my particular version of a podcast generator:
#!/bin/bash
# call with $1=url, $2=mp3 file
# to stop recording, kill the mplayer process (killall mplayer)
# create unique name based on md5 hash of stream url and output mp3 file
output=/tmp/`echo $1 $2 | md5sum | awk '{print $1}'`
# make the fifo buffer
mkfifo "$output"
# start mplayer, dump the video (if any) to /dev/null
mplayer "$1" -ao pcm:file="$output" -vo null -vc dummy &
# and start transcoding from the fifo -> mp3 file
lame -S "$output" "$2"
rm "$output"
Kudos and extending the functionality
On April 10th, 2006 woodside says:
I have hacked away on this to a point that it works pretty well for me. It am still having a few minor issues on the rss document ceation when I use the same script to record a few different programs throughout the week. It hasn't risen to the level of actually digging into it again, though. All in all, it works great.
I have been looking for a way to post-process the files to add bookmarks to the files, because one of the shows I record has 10 minute music breaks while they cut to local programming. I am looking for a way to extend this script by overlaying a bookmark. For example, 27 minutes into the show I want to insert a bookmark so that when they cut to music, I hit the forward button and advance to the next bookmark, which would be just before the cut back to the show. This assumes that the show is consistent with cuts, but that doesn't seem to be a problem.
Thanks for the excellent article.
I've brushed up the script
On September 15th, 2005 Rick (not verified) says:
I've brushed up the script a bit so that you only need one
and everything is pretty much passed from the crontab.
See it here
Cheers,
Rick
Link -
On July 20th, 2007 Wong Seuol (not verified) says:
Link is not working.. Thanks.. I would like to see ur scripted...
Thanks
Dead link
On October 30th, 2006 Kinney (not verified) says:
The link you refer to above appears to be dead. Would love to see the revised code.
Re: I've brushed up the script
On September 15th, 2005 Phil Salkie says:
Nice job! Much cleaner than my hack-and-patch approach... Thanks!
Firefox Live Bookmarks and the enclosure tag
On August 11th, 2005 eric.john.miller says:
Firefox live bookmarks do not appear to support the enclosure tag. Do you have a workaround for this?
I've been thinking about putting together something like this for a while. Thanks for a great article!
Re: Firefox Live Bookmarks and the enclosure tag
On August 12th, 2005 Phil Salkie says:
Sure - it breaks the "link" feature on some news aggregators, but makes the live bookmarks work again. Sigh...
Change this bit of perl:
link=>$o->{'channel'}{'link'}, \
To this:
link=>'file://$FILE', \
With this change (assuming you have some useful plugin like Plugger or MPlayer Plugin) clicking on the live bookmark starts playing the captured file. This is really how it should have been in the article - it's much more useful than having the link to the homepage, plus that link is in the title section anyway.
Re: Firefox Live Bookmarks and the enclosure tag
On August 14th, 2005 eric.john.miller says:
Thanks, that did the trick!
Mplayer?
On August 1st, 2005 tpurl says:
Why not use streamripper instead? As long as you're writing your content to a file, streamripper works very well and requires fewer command switches.
Mplayer?
On August 7th, 2006 Sean Edwards (not verified) says:
Mplayer, ecasound, sox . . . there are many command-line audio tools. I prefer ecasound myself.
Re: Mplayer?
On August 8th, 2005 Phil Salkie says:
(This comment got deleted because I'd managed to cross-up my user names... Here's my second try at it.)
Streamripper was one of the programs I looked at when I first tried to do time-based capture. I thought it would be the do-everything package that I wanted, but I found that it
1) Has almost no Linux documentation available from the website
2) Has a limited number of stream types that it can access
3) Has timed duration, but not timed start
4) Can't transcode (i.e. take a RealPlayer stream and save it as MP3)
5) Has ID3V2 file tagging, but it wasn't clear if you could tag with data that didn't come from the stream itself.
That being said, it seems to be a pretty capable package, and if it saves the shows you want in the format you want, great - you're absolutely right - it saves some messing around in the script, especially if you can get the MP3 tags to do what you want. But its main purpose seems to be to capture _songs_ from internet radio streams (like shoutcast), not whole _programs_.
So, it was sufficiently not what I was looking for that I opted to take the program which I was already using as a listener tool (MPlayer) and make it be what I wanted (a VCR for Internet Radio) by using a shell script. (Plus, that seemed to be a cool enough thing to do to write an article about.)
Thanks for the article
On December 1st, 2007 Joel (not verified) says:
Thanks for the article. It should be a good reference, even I don't need to do exactly what you're doing.