2005 Text Mode Browser Roundup
Editor's Note: This article has been updated since its original posting.
Browsing the Web in text mode has a long history. Initially, text mode was all there was, with the CERN Line Mode Browser (also called www). The ever-present Lynx made the jump to full-screen text mode, as opposed to line-by-line, in late 1992. Lynx continues to be maintained and extended today. Incidentally, Lynx originally was a browser for Gopher and some in-house university hypertext systems. Emacs/W3 came next, in 1993, and was written in Emacs Lisp.
In late 1998, W3M came out of Japan, and in 1999 Links was released by Czech programmer Mikulas Patocka. Both these projects have since forked to different degrees. For example, ELinks, an offshoot of Links, now is considered to be a separate project.
Considering the speed and convenience text mode browsers offer, even over SSH connection from half a continent away, text mode browsing is supremely useful. So let's take a look at the current state of text mode browsers.
Ported to almost every current system under the sun and available on most general purpose SSH-accessible systems in the world, Lynx is a mature piece of software. As such, it has accumulated well over a hundred command-line options and obscure features. It still does the basics well, including SSL these days, and it is quick compared to any graphical browser.
Lynx renders pages in color or monochrome, based on your preference. It can display pages in any of a few dozen character sets--Arabic, Hebrew and Japanese, to name a few--and can be integrated into any printing and storage regime. This is due to supporting user/administrator-defined commands on print and download requests. Lynx comes with extensive documentation, including a speech-friendly set of help files tailored for blind and visually handicapped users. Lynx also has a kiosk mode, so you can restrict the set of allowable actions and URLs.
At the time of its release, Emacs/W3 was touted as yet another reason why a user would never have to leave Emacs. It can do UTF-8 as well as Emacs can, and it understands simple CSS. Emacs/W3 has suffered bit rot since 1999, and it is hard to get up and running these days. It does not understand XHTML, so modern pages have bits and pieces of code sticking out all over the place. Currently, Emacs/W3 needs quite a bit of rework and is not recommended for use.
W3M originally was intended to be a pager, like the less pager but with HTML support. The original author felt Lynx was big and slow and wanted a quick, light replacement. Thus, W3M came into being. Over time, W3M has grown, and nowadays it has a somewhat bigger memory image than Lynx does while viewing the same page.
W3M was the first text browser to handle table rendering well, and it transforms frames to tables for convenient viewing. Coming from Japan, it has good support for exotic scripts and UTF-8. At first W3M was purely bilingual, offering good support for English and Japanese scripts, but improvements to support the broader world languages is ongoing. In addition, the browser offers the unexpected feature of being able to render images in-line on your xterm or framebuffer console. This feature is not really relevant to this comparison, but it is worth a mention. W3M also offers tabbed browsing.
W3M's shortcomings are few. W3M does not do incremental rendering. Also, you cannot do anything else while W3M is loading a page, even if you have several tabs open.
As the name suggests, Links was created as a Lynx replacement to offer saner table renderings and a smaller footprint. In these areas, Links has succeeded; Links 1.0.0pre12 has the smallest footprint of the tested browsers discussed here. On a side note, Links2 seems to be a mostly graphical fork and thus was not considered for this review.
Links does offer saner table rendering than Lynx does; Links rendering is on par with W3M's. Development is frozen, so only bug fixes are being accepted. As a result, Links is both fast and stable. It can run downloads in the background, and it does incremental rendering. Like Lynx, Links has an anonymous/kiosk mode for use on public computers.
As for drawbacks, Links does not support HTTP authentication. UTF-8 support is partial, and no support is offered for Chinese, Japanese or Korean languages (CJK), even when the page is UTF-8-encoded.
Webinar: 8 Signs You’re Beyond Cron
11am CDT, April 29th
Join Linux Journal and Pat Cameron, Director of Automation Technology at HelpSystems, as they discuss the eight primary advantages of moving beyond cron job scheduling. In this webinar, you’ll learn about integrating cron with an enterprise scheduler.Join us!
- Not So Dynamic Updates
- New Products
- Users, Permissions and Multitenant Sites
- Security in Three Ds: Detect, Decide and Deny
- Flexible Access Control with Squid Proxy
- Tighten Up SSH
- DevOps: Everything You Need to Know
- Solving ODEs on Linux
- Non-Linux FOSS: MenuMeters
- Android Candy: Bluetooth Auto Connect