Software Freedom for Macedonia?
September 21st, 2002 by David Sugar in
When I first heard that I would be visiting to speak in Macedonia, my initial thoughts were of a small isolated Eastern European nation. I had spoken in many other countries recently, usually about GNU Bayonne. The people who organized this event, however, wanted to use it to help launch a national free software movement in Macedonia, and so I thought for a long time, so I agreed and decided I would go and speak there primarily about software freedom, an issue of deep importance to me.
I first received the offer to speak in Macedonia while I was traveling abroad. In fact, I was attending the Bristol Software Conference at the time, and then a week later visiting France for what has now become the annual Libre Software Meeting. It was on my return to the US, and a family tragedy, that initially made me cancel all my immediate travel plans, however, including this event.
A week before the event, I was contacted, and, considering the importance of being able to reach and speak with hackers in that part of the world, I did finally consent to go. It was not until the day before that we were able to get airline tickets booked, however, so this trip was already very much in doubt before it happened, and seemed at best precarious. This led me to have even lower expectations.
What is "officially" called the "Former Yugoslav" Republic of Macedonia is a landlocked nation of 2 million people surrounded by the Kosovo region of Serbia in the north, Albania in the west, Greece in the south, and Bulgaria in the east. In that they were having national elections and a national holiday around the time I would be there, it was impossible for them to make travel arrangements for me to fly into the one major airport in the country. I was also reminded that Macedonia is not considered "safe" for air travel, in that the nation is not considered to have air traffic safety up to western European standards. Finally, my own State Department suggested American citizens should not travel to this country. With such overwhelming negative comments, my expectations had reached a very low point indeed, but I had agreed to go, and, at the last minute, the flight arrangements came through.
To visit Macedonia, I was flown to Sofia, in Bulgaria. Bulgaria is perhaps the most friendly of Macedonia's neighbors, and perhaps the easiest approach into the country. From there it is only a two or three hour drive to Skopje (pronounced Scopia), with, as I later learned, anywhere from a 1 to 12 hour delay at the border crossing being possible.
While I had many negative expectations about the country, I found that many of these expectations were very true, but of Bulgaria. The drive to the border was perhaps the most depressing drive I ever took. Everywhere one looked in Bulgaria there were large buildings falling apart. This was a very consistent theme. This trip reached a very low point when the car I was in had an accident about 20km for the border in some nameless Bulgarian town. The car was undrivable, and we were too far from the border for anyone's cell phone to work, so we were stranded, until the police would allow themselves to be paid, and we could arrange to get the car towed to the border.
Unlike most borders, there are checkpoints at both ends, and a kind of 1km no-man's land in between where time can stand still for many hours depending on the mood and circumstances of the border police. My entry into Macedonia consisted of helping to push an old Russian-made car with a smashed front end over this border with a short (under two hour) delay in "no-mans" land fairly late in the evening of my first day in the Balkans. This was clearly the most challenging nation I had ever visited. Little did I expect then that it would be very much worth all these difficulties to do so.
Even from the very first village we passed through after getting a cab at the border, it was immediately clear Macedonia was place very different, and much more alive than Bulgaria. Skopje itself has perhaps from 1/3 up to 1/2 of the entire population of the country in it, making it a fairly large and dynamic city.
I was staying next door to the Russian embassy, and the humour of this was not lost upon me. However, Skopje is very much a 24 hour city, and, even as an American, I felt and found I was perfectly safe wherever in the city I went. In fact, I felt safer in Skopje than many other foreign cities I have visited, and even than in some American ones at night. It also helped that English was a fairly common second language, and, unlike in some European countries, people that know English are quite willing to use it. I suppose trying to speak Macedonian is likely to break one's tongue, so it is no doubt out of politeness that they do not expect one to!
I could describe the extensive night life of Skopje, but I did not visit there for that purpose. I also learned much about Macedonian culture and history while I was there and visited their national museum. I found that to be equally interesting. Certainly, in the place that gave the world the Cyrillic alphabet, there is a long and deep understanding of the need to share knowledge for the benefit of society.
My trip was sponsored by the Macedonian magazine publication, [PCInfo+], and I was invited to speak at an event they called ExpoCom. This event was originally expanded to be a full week long. However, when it was announced I was coming to speak on software freedom, a number of vendors and speakers withdrew and ExpoCom was shortened by a few days. I learned this was because the Microsoft Adriatic representative and the local Microsoft reseller in Macedonia had contacted the speakers and vendors who were going to attend, and requested they withdraw from ExpoCom and offered other considerations if they would do so.
[PCInfo+] had at one time been a more traditional PC magazine much like [PC Week] or similar publications that cover proprietary software and hardware. When Igor become managing editor, and I think it was some two years ago, he focused attention and coverage on GNU/Linux, and the local hacker community. The immediate result of this was the Adriatic Microsoft rep asked their Macedonian reseller to stop future advertising in [PCInfo+.]
Very recently they had an amusing cover for PCInfo+ where they had a "Tux" penguin suck a "Microsoft" juicebox dry. This prompted the Microsoft Adriatic offices to phone each and every one of the local advertisers of [PCInfo+], and any that would withdraw from further advertising were offered "special" software licensing terms. Most recently, they had contacted the the printing house that [PCInfo+] uses. However, Igor will be telling his story for the world press directly, so I will leave it to him to fill in most of the details first hand.
I suppose in a country with a stronger civil history this would be scandalous. In fact, Macedonia has a poor history for enforcing laws and certainly, especially considering the short history of independence, less strong a connection between civil law and constitutional ideals than we enjoy here. Copyright, as a concept in Macedonia, is actually practiced somewhat on the French model. Authors have permanent and non-transferable "intellectual" rights, but can severably transfer "commercial" rights to others. In practice, actual enforcement on copyright restrictions has been very minimal in Macedonia to date.
With their low experience and civil history, there are many risks that they face. I was told that in Serbia, a separate and specific "software licensing" law was passed last year after much lobbying of that government which are neither based on constitutional, contractual, or civil law as it existed before. These laws permit private software companies to directly audit commercial firms in Serbia at will and permits the state to then close commercial businesses if the business is not in full software license, with "compliance" as defined by the firm initiating a software "audit". This also seems to be a slap to the concept of due process. There is some fear that similar laws may be passed in Macedonia.
As it was, ExpoCom was a much smaller and more intimate event than I had originally anticipated. It was held in a very small convention center. But, while most small Macedonian companies were discouraged from participating, many well known foreign companies unlikely to be effected by pressures choose to attend and present at it anyway. Most of these presentations were actually, for me, rather boring traditional marketing presentations. Most were, for me, somewhat boring, and I have little interest in mostly proprietary products or services from companies like Fujitsu and Assman.
My talk was at the end of the event, the "footnote", if you will. Even so, it was the most heavily attended presentation, even though I actually required the audience to actually think and ask questions rather than just listen to some slick video or slide presentation. I mostly spoke about software freedom and the right to study, and a little about GNU Bayonne. The audience was very receptive and much more energetic than I saw at the other presentations.
Later I had the chance to meet with a number of members of the Macedonian hacker community. I would say there are probably about 200 free software hackers in Macedonia as a whole, with the vast majority being in Skopje itself. While some Macedonian hackers are are in similar circumstances and viewpoint to many we have in the US who work part or full time in various commercial companies, a vast majority of Macedonian hackers are under 20, and perhaps a majority are under 18. It is this latter group which is most visibly prevalent and highly cohesive. I think the small size, uniformity of experience, and geographical proximity (being in one city) of Macedonian hackers accounts for this uniformity of viewpoint and goals and high level of social integration that they share.
Among this group of Macedonian hackers is Angov Arangel. While I would never suggest getting in a car with him, as such cars seem to have a natural tendency to crash into other cars even though he never drives, he is involved in getting this Macedonian hacker community together under a new Macedonian national Free Software organization. This organization was originally going to be formed and announced during ExpoCom itself, but they had not completed everything necessary by that date.
The problem the hacker community faces in Macedonia is that, especially in regard to their age and historic isolation, they do not have anyone who fully understands free software philosophy in the country. They have ideas of what this means and certainly can and have read things including the many things Richard Stallman has written, but they lack the full perspective or history that we enjoy here and so lack some of the understanding that comes from it. It was this reason, I think, that they wanted specifically an FSF "speaker" present. As it happens, I mostly spoke about free software philosophy and our common values while I was there, including in my main speech, and so I think this part of my trip worked out very well.
Returning from Macedonia also proved a most unique challenge. Igor was late picking me up at the hotel that morning. We were delayed several hours in the border no-mans land once again. By the time we reached Sofia, they had already closed boarding for the flight, and even though it had a half-hour before departing, there was no means for them to get me on the airplane. There is only one daily flight, as it happens, from Sofia to Frankfurt. Also, while there were later flights to other German cities, that particular flight connected with the very last flight available from Germany to the US that day.
I have learned that the people of Macedonia do care deeply about software freedom, and that they relate to it in regard to their own unique cultural history and national identity. With their recent elections and change of government, there is new hope that software freedom will become part of the agenda of their national government, for it already is part of their society.
Special Magazine Offer -- Free Gift with Subscription
Receive a free digital copy of Linux Journal's System Administration Special Edition as well as instant online access to current and past issues. CLICK HERE for offer
Linux Journal: delivering readers the advice and inspiration they need to get the most out of their Linux systems since 1994.
Subscribe now!
The Latest
Newsletter
Tech Tip Videos
- Nov-19-09
- Nov-04-09
Recently Popular
From the Magazine
December 2009, #188
If last month's Infrastrucuture issue was too "big" for you then try on this month's Embedded issue. Find out how to use Player for programming mobile robots, build a humidity controller for your root cellar, find out how to reduce the boot time of your embedded system, and if you're new to embedded systems find out the basics that go into one. You can also read about the Beagle Board, the Mesh Potato and a spate of other interestingly named items. And along with our regular columns don't miss our new monthly column: Economy Size Geek.
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Facebook








Brain washed people
On October 2nd, 2009 Anonymous (not verified) says:
Slavonic FYROMians, as you call them, previously Vardarians and before that pure Bulgarians should not be blamed because they were brain washed by communist Tito and now days by fascist VMRO. You should pity them because they are Bulgarians who due to brain washing are ashamed to admit it. Except of course all these free minded who redescovered their origins and got Bulgarian passports.
As for Alexander, FYROMians, except those in Pelogonia, live in the country of Dardanians and Illyrians and other enemies of the ancient Macedon, which clearly was Hellenic and created the Hellenistic world and spread the Greek language all the way to Asia and Egypt.
OSS community should be careful in adopting country names not recognized by UN in order not to contribute further to this conflict between FYROM and neighboring countries.
By the way, as long as 3 mil people in Northern Greece live in the region of ancient Macedonia and call themselves Macedonian Greeks, Greece will be unable to recognize FYROM, which truely is Western Bulgaria previously occupied by Yugoslavia, under another name, much as it will not be able to recognize a Peloponnesian country or a Thessalian country outside its borders.
Re: Software Freedom for Macedonia?
On December 7th, 2002 Anonymous says:
I think it's nice of your side to describe your trip to Macedonia or FYROM if you prefer as a nice thing. Altough I am for software freedom for Macedonia,FYROM, I think while we argue about the historical matter with our neighbours, we should concentrate on the matter which was brought up by somebody who has interest to bring some of its knowledge on the Balkan. Thank you for your interest in this matter and greetings from SmartFreak form MAcedonia(FYROM).
Re: Software Freedom for Macedonia?
On October 20th, 2002 Anonymous says:
Interesting and for sure more than good that our neigbhoors are interesting for us so much.
We have here one saying like this:
Behind the good horse (or car if u want) there is lot of dust
So, Go Greek ppl, make allways a coments against us, finnally the time will show who is wright.
Regards
ohoho
BTW Do u know that Greek on thair own lenguage means "GAY", so they preffer to call them selfs Hellas
:)
You manage neither English
On October 2nd, 2009 Anonymous (not verified) says:
You manage neither English not the Greek language vey well. You only show your ignorance and stupidity. Moron is a Greek word and fits you perfectly.
R.T.F.H.
On October 1st, 2002 Anonymous says:
Read The F(riendly) History...
ask your B.P(rofessor)F.H.
Re: wrong subject
On September 25th, 2002 Anonymous says:
The subject should be "My trip in Bulgaria and Macedonia"
Re: Software Freedom for Macedonia?
On September 25th, 2002 Anonymous says:
I can tell that there is two options about Greek-Macedonian conflict:
1. They dont have much education about their history and history on the Balkan people at al.
2. They know everything perfect but they dont want to believe in that so they tell facts just to profit from that.
http://www.balcanica.org/history/maps.html
I think that is enough.
born Macedonian living Macedonian
Re: Install the history
On September 25th, 2002 Anonymous says:
"... if you think that Bulgarian version of the history is free ok, just share it with us, but don't try to force us to install it ..."
This explain a lot. That's what you do Macedonian: just install
the new version of history (if the history has a bug - e.g not writen appropriately). That's what you study in shool:
to install the history.
Note that patch for history is distributed by your government :))
Freedom: software, knowledge, mind
On September 24th, 2002 vladimirg (not verified) says:
On knowledge: I'm afraid only the future would allow the opinions about history on all countries in the region (Macedonia, Trukey, Greece, Bulgaria) to converge on simple facts. I hope historians and people who write school textbooks on history will become conscientious enough.
On mind and software: Because the future is in the future, and we need something to happen _now_, we must concentrate on the things that stick as together and are moving us into a better future. The point is the free software development (in wide sense).
Simple history facts: Cyrillic script was modelled on the Greek upper-case letters in the early Middle Ages and was first introduced in Bulgaria in the 9th century(!). Much later, it became the
Re: Software Freedom for Macedonia?
On September 24th, 2002 Anonymous says:
1. There are very few USA citizens whoever actually leave their country, never mind their continent. Cool that you traveled, and cool what you went for.
2. Microsoft is currently getting grief from the European Union over monopolistic behaviour. The things that they did are currently described as "restraint of trade." I'm not sure of Macedonia's status as regards the EU (to my shame...) but It would be worth anyone who was and is being affected by this to contact the EU Monopolies Commission.
3. The free software movement should contact every company that was affected by M$'s behaviour. Showing the simple financial benefits of using Open-Source Software, as well as the ability to avoid the software audit problems, will convince most. Especially as they won't have to worry about a large multi-national dictating terms of trade.
4. Since the Open-Source Software/Free Software philosophy is based upon an accurate measurement of the energy costs of software developement, the computing service industry could be incredibly strong. This would give a large number of employment opportunities for the Free Software programmers.
4. The Macedonian Govt. should be involved immediately. A large multi-national Corporation has just tried to bully/bribe a number of their local companies to the detriment of their local industry.
5. The Macedonian Dept. of Industry should be involved as this is an ideal opportunity for Macedonia to develope an indigenous Software industry.
6. The EU is considering the wholesale adoption of Open-Source Software. This would also be an opportunity for the Macedonian Govt. to not only bolster their indigenous software industry, but also to cut their software costs by up to 70%, while ensuring that the money spent stays inside the Macedonian economy, rather than going to their trade deficit.
7. Considering the age-range of the local Free-software advocates/programmers, there is also the opportunity to cost-effectively develope an excellent Graduate/Post-Graduate university research program, which would translate, long-term, into a large amount of foreign capital and trade flowing into Macedonia.
Go Free Software. By behaving like that publicly Microsoft have completely screwed up. Use the opportunity wisely and well.
mailto:Billy.Smith@newham.ac.uk
Meaure Twice.
Post new comment