Nokia Wants To Lock Up Ogg

The open-source Ogg Theora video format is an important part of keeping video free on the web — but it won't be for long if Nokia gets its way.

In an objection filed with the World Wide Web Consortium against the selection of Ogg Theora as a baseline standard for web video, Nokia cites the lack of digital rights management (DRM) in the format makes it a "non-starter" for Hollywood. According to Nokia, the open source format is really proprietary, and DRM is an essential part of web video.

The good news is that the W3C has traditionally taken a stance against proprietary and restricted formats, so the likelihood of the Consortium kowtowing to the proprietary pressures is about as likely as Microsoft releasing Vista under the GPL.

Read more.


Justin Ryan is a Contributing Editor for Linux Journal.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Complete misrepresentation

Oluseyi's picture

First of all, the "lack of DRM" is not a complaint made by Nokia or Apple. The unclear patent status, rather, is. Nokia in fact suggested relying on older technologies whose patents have expired, both because of their widespread availability/support and because of their clear legal status.

Further, Ogg has no business being part of the HTML spec, anyway. It can be a candidate in a separate W3C recommendation regarding internet video, but it should be a part of the HyperTEXT Markup Language technical recommendation.