Home ›

Clementine: a Port of Amarok 1.4 to QT 4

Sep 13, 2010  By Michael Reed
 in

Clementine is a port of Amarok 1.4 to QT 4, giving users an application that fits in well with KDE 4 while still resembling the previous version of the library-based music player. As I've commented in the past, acceptance of KDE 4 wasn't helped by the fact that the developers took it upon themselves to redesign some of the most popular apps such as Konqueror and Amarok.

As Clementine is a fork of the 1.4 branch of Amarok that has been ported to QT 4, users can expect a layout and functionality that replicates the KDE 3.x era of the program alongside updates that ensure that it fits in well with the look of the KDE 4.x desktop environment. To jog the memory of former users, this amounts to a two pane design, with the music library on the left hand side of the window and most of the display taken up by the larger playlist window on the right. Each of the two panes has a real-time search box at the top. In addition, the program has some features for the playback of online audio streams such as internet radio stations.

Overall it's a slick, some might say optimal, approach that gives the user everything they need in a layout that makes very efficient use of space. The oft-quoted design maxim that perfection has been reached, not when there is nothing left to add, but instead, when there is nothing that can be removed, is key to the design of the classic Amarok GUI. I prefer it, and frankly, I'm not alone.

Clementine installed without problems under Kubuntu 10.4, using the .deb from the official website. There are also Windows and MacOSX installers available.

Conclusion

I'm sure that the KDE devs feel that they took Amorok 2.0 in the direction that represents the best future for the users and KDE itself. However, they took a risk when they decided to completely redesign one of the most popular and well liked KDE applications in a move that has, so far, resulted in very few end user benefits. In hindsight, they might have been better off if they had created a new media application rather than attempting to succeed Amarok directly. I've no-doubt that Amarok 2.0 will be the better platform for expansion in the future, but for now, you'll find me running Clementine.

The Clementine website.

______________________

UK based freelance writer Michael Reed writes about technology, retro computing, geek culture and gender politics.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Nice review! While I'm

Jack's picture
Submitted by Jack (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 21:35.

Nice review! While I'm personally on the Amarok 2 train, I can certainly understand the users of this application. It's kind of totally awesome, actually, to have people pick up a project and port it like that. I'm sure it will add a lot to the scene, and I'm glad these users/devs can take the original design even further than the original Amarok had gone.

To each his own, of course. That's the beauty of Linux- not one size fits all, but there is a size for you.

I'm glad to Find out about

Anonymous's picture
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 21:10.

I'm glad to Find out about this project! As much as Amarok 2 has working right, it has a thousand hits of polish missing that Clementine retains.

Amarok2 UI is already almost perfect, just tweak it!

Fri13's picture
Submitted by Fri13 (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 16:42.

I have configured Amarok 2.2.3 to be like Amarok 1.4.x and there are only very few small changes what can not be applied. Like the play buttons place. But neither is all buttons in original position in clementine.

What I really love in Amarok 2.2.3 is the simplicity to just to give the database and playlist to front of me. Hide everything else.

As example, these are the UI's what I use. Typically the minimal controls are used in netbook while the bigger one in desktop computer.
http://i.imgur.com/XaCFX.png
http://i.imgur.com/J6Alg.png

Amarok 2 users do not have many reasons to use earlier version of the Amarok.

The Amarok2 has gone long way since 2.x series start.

I only miss few features myself, what actually applies to 1.4.x series as well. It is the database change from Albums -> CD's. You see, the Amarok does not follow the standard to handle a CD as CD. But it handles every CD as a different album. I have half of my music collections a albums what has more than one CD. Especially with voicebooks are with multiple CD's, like 26 or 32. So every CD in one album, is needed to rename as different album. Other mediaplayers follows the CD number and allows database to be shown as Artists > Album > CD. But Amarok only allows Artists > Album.

That is very critical thing what Amarok should get fixed, that album is not same thing as the CD. It is the some way rare problem among music culture as well.

Amarok allows user to write to metadata the CD number, but it does not allow to filter and archive music with that metadata.

Best music player ever

markh's picture
Submitted by markh (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 11:16.

I am new to KDE (using kubuntu 10.04 right now after seeing the disaster that gnome3 is going to be).....I hated the Amarok that came with it (it seemed like a half-*** version of iTunes). Anyway I just downloaded Clementine and I LOVE IT!!!

Also with all of this backporting/forking to KDE 3.5 that I see going on I am really close to giving Kubuntu trinity a try.

I have to agree!

Anonymous's picture
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 09/19/2010 - 12:10.

Much as I want t' be thankin' them swabbies polishin' the
decks o' t' ship Amarok 2.0, I be putin' my oars behind the
crew workin' the decks o' the good ship Clementine!

Ship Amarok 2.0, shiver me timbers, can't seem to sail on
me ocean. Not er sound does she make, no matter how much
sheet they put on her.

Ship Clementine be makin' waves that be swampin' all t'
boats still floatin' in me ocean.

Best comment o' th' day.

Webmistress's picture
Submitted by Webmistress on Sun, 09/19/2010 - 12:29.

Best comment of the day. Thanks for playing. :)

Katherine Druckman is webmistress at LinuxJournal.com. You might find her on Twitter or at the Southwest Drupal Summit

Finally, a stable music

@BaloneyGeek's picture
Submitted by @BaloneyGeek (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 10:36.

Finally, a stable music player which does not randomly crash.

And the best part is, I finally have AmaroK on Windows! Clementine's Windows support is amazing!

What I like

Doug.Roberts's picture
Submitted by Doug.Roberts on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 10:46.

What I *really* like about Clementine vs. Amarok is that it does not ask me for my damn password each time I start it. Amarok has this thing about using Kwallet to authenticate just in case I might want to connect to one of the web music sources which requires authentication.

I also like that it is streamlined, positively nimble compared to Amarok.

As a side note, I've given up on KDE after being a user for 4 years. It similarly is just too heavyweight for me.

--Doug

don't use kwallet or set password to blank

Bart Burroughs's picture
Submitted by Bart Burroughs (not verified) on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 19:37.

The password issue is because you created a password. if you leave it blank and accept the warning about an insecure password it will never ask you for a password again. Amarok 2 is better in my opinion but, as should always be the case, linux is all about choice and if Clementine rocks your world I would never presume to tell you your wrong.

Not exactly

Doug.Roberts's picture
Submitted by Doug.Roberts on Mon, 09/13/2010 - 20:12.

The password issue derived from the fact that Amarok, at some point, asked me if I wanted to use Kwallet to manage my passwords. Stupidly, instead of saying "No", I said "Yes".

And then I could not find out how to tell Amarok to please quit using Kwallet to prompt me for a password, apparently to be used on some internet music service to which I had never subscribed and that I never needed or wanted.

I despise overly convoluted, overly complex software. I design software for a living: I would have fired the chief designer of Amarok for that mess, had the application been developed in a "for pay" environment instead of as an open source app.

Clementine doesn't exactly rock my world, but it does perform its task pretty efficiently, and I appreciate that.

--Doug

Disable the password question

Fri13's picture
Submitted by Fri13 (not verified) on Tue, 09/14/2010 - 01:50.

Have you tried going to settings and disabling the online services plugins? Like Magnatune Store and Jamendo?

Those settings are btw about the distributor, not about Amarok. I never got the password question because as far I know, they are not configured so by default. But on the distributions what are free version from the commercial distributors or so on, they usually enable jamendo, Last.FM and other services what tries to connect in first place to services and Amarok asks the password.

And if you want to remove the Amarok from KWallet, open the Kwallet settings and go from there remove the Amarok from the password list. Then start Amarok and it asks again where it should store the password.

Webcast
More Resources
How to Build an Optimal Hadoop Cluster to Store and Maintain Unlimited Amounts of Data Using Microservers

Realizing the promise of Apache® Hadoop® requires the effective deployment of compute, memory, storage and networking to achieve optimal results. With its flexibility and multitude of options, it is easy to over or under provision the server infrastructure, resulting in poor performance and high TCO. Join us for an in depth, technical discussion with industry experts from leading Hadoop and server companies who will provide insights into the key considerations for designing and deploying an optimal Hadoop cluster.

Learn More

Sponsored by AMD

White Paper
More Resources
Red Hat White Paper: Using an Open Source Framework to Catch the Bad Guy

Built-in forensics, incident response, and security with Red Hat Enterprise Linux 6

Every security policy provides guidance and requirements for ensuring adequate protection of information and data, as well as high-level technical and administrative security requirements for a system in a given environment. Traditionally, providing security for a system focuses on the confidentiality of the information on it. However, protecting the data integrity and system and data availability is just as important. For example, when processing United States intelligence information, there are three attributes that require protection: confidentiality, integrity, and availability.

Learn more about catching the bad guy in this free white paper.

Learn More

Sponsored by DLT Solutions