2008 Readers' Choice Survey

January 21st, 2008 by LJ Staff

Your rating: None Average: 4.8 (9 votes)

The 2008 Readers' Choice survey is now closed. We received nearly 6,000 responses -- thank you to everyone who participated.

Winners will be announced in the June 2008 issue of Linux Journal (on newsstands in early May).

Special Note: We've been asked why we didn't share the survey responses immediately with respondents. Normally we would, however LJ's Readers' Choice Awards are a special annual event for us, one we treat as more of a ceremony. We want to give the winners special honor.
__________________________


Special Magazine Offer -- Free Gift with Subscription
Receive a free digital copy of Linux Journal's System Administration Special Edition as well as instant online access to current and past issues. CLICK HERE for offer

Linux Journal: delivering readers the advice and inspiration they need to get the most out of their Linux systems since 1994.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
e-okul's picture

??

On March 9th, 2009 e-okul (not verified) says:

Where are urpmi and Mandriva control centre (mcc)?

e-okul's picture

REader

On March 8th, 2009 e-okul (not verified) says:

There should be a "None of the above" or at least "Unsure" option for the questions in this survey. We may try to be everywhere all the time, but not every LJ reader will have experience with all categories!

have's picture

hello

On March 5th, 2009 have (not verified) says:

I agree with you that FluxBox is not complete Desktop environment like GNOME or KDE or CDE, but you can use FluxBox or BlackBox and ... as your primary Desktop!

toki's picture

toki

On February 25th, 2009 toki (not verified) says:

Yep, I agree with the above posters, I can't vote for Python as my favorite *Programming* language?

Magma's picture

Hıms..

On January 30th, 2009 Magma (not verified) says:

Magma is a general purpose programming language! It is interpreted as opposed to compiled. It is dynamically typed as opposed to statically typed, but definitely strongly typed. ...and back in the early 90s it may have been seen as a scripting language, but that moniker is no longer accurate. It is a general purpose language from which the full range of applications can be built, and has been for quite some time now.

If you must differentiate, please do so on the basis of compiled vs interpreted, but today Python is no longer your father's scripting language.

Anonymous's picture

Business Applications

On December 6th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

There's only 1 category for non-admin software here altogether it seems. Well no wonder we can get the rest of the computing world to see the beauty of Linux if we don't spread our love for 3rd party business and personal apps.

We presently used a variation of free Nolapro and WebERP to do our business work. We recently ditched sugarcrm, which I know is popular, as well as some smaller apps, but none of these types of programs are brought up for widespread sharing.

Why is the community so closed-minded about giving props for good end-user software?

Anonymous's picture

Fluxbox is not a Desktop

On October 28th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

Fluxbox is not a Desktop Environment. It's a Window Manager ;)

saç ekimi's picture

I checked

On October 27th, 2008 saç ekimi (not verified) says:

Where I did not have experience with the item, I checked "Other" and put in "Don't Use"

key's picture

key

On October 26th, 2008 key (not verified) says:

where I had nothing I liked I checked Other : "none"

Bedava Chat's picture

Oh well

On September 20th, 2008 Bedava Chat (not verified) says:

where I had nothing I liked I checked Other : "none"

Bedava Chat's picture

Fluxbox is not a Desktop

On September 19th, 2008 Bedava Chat (not verified) says:

Thanks you.

ThomasJLane's picture

Business Applications

On February 12th, 2008 ThomasJLane (not verified) says:

There's only 1 category for non-admin software here altogether it seems. Well no wonder we can get the rest of the computing world to see the beauty of Linux if we don't spread our love for 3rd party business and personal apps.

We presently used a variation of free Nolapro and WebERP to do our business work. We recently ditched sugarcrm, which I know is popular, as well as some smaller apps, but none of these types of programs are brought up for widespread sharing.

Why is the community so closed-minded about giving props for good end-user software?

My goodness, who is the know-it-all that designed this questionnaire? Among other thigh-slappers:

22. What is your favorite Linux software development tool?
What about the GNU Compiler Collection? The essential development tool without no Linux kernel and no GNU/Linux distribution would be available at all? Well, perhaps there is a Intel C/C++ compiler based GNU/Linux distribution around I do not know about.

24. What is your favorite system administration tool?
Never stroke me that OpenSSH was a system administration tool although I am using it everyday in non-sysadmin-mode.

initialzero's picture

Security

On January 29th, 2008 initialzero (not verified) says:

I can't believe one of the best security tools, AppArmor has been overlooked as an option.

Michael Trent's picture

I agree. Application Armor

On June 18th, 2008 Michael Trent (not verified) says:

I agree. Application Armor is a great tool which I've been a fan of for a few years. I'm surprised it hasn't been considered.

Mike

beer's picture

In the "22. What is your

On March 25th, 2008 beer (not verified) says:

In the "22. What is your favorite Linux software development tool?" question, there is a significant option that has been overlooked - Sun Studio software. Freely available on Solaris and Linux platforms, its optimizing compilers, source and memory debuggers, thread and performance analyzers, and IDE make a well integrated toolchain for C/C++/Fortran developers.

Anonymous's picture

bad poll, no cookie

On January 26th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

I can't really participate in this survey; it has far too many flaws.

Programing language vs scripting language. Desktop environment vs window manager. "Communication tools", "security tools", "software development tools" and "package managers" all have massive confusion as to what type or level of tool they are talking about (netbeans, autoconf, emacs (no vi!) -- iptables, nmap, Coverity Scan -- dpkg *and* apt, but no aptitude). Email needs to be added to communication tools or comm. tools needs to be split up (at least irc, IM, voice). Audio tool is a title that does not sound like music players, it sounds like editing tools (audacity, jokosher).

I don't expect amateur polls to be perfect, but I expect *some* thought and effort.

kabin's picture

Good Projects

On September 10th, 2008 kabin (not verified) says:

its very nice Documents.

Athropos's picture

I agree that Python should

On January 26th, 2008 Athropos (not verified) says:

I agree that Python should not be reduced to a "simple" scripting language. Anything that can be done in C/C++/Java/... can be done in Python.

agc's picture

Yep, I agree with the above ... where's my Python?

On February 2nd, 2008 agc (not verified) says:

Yep, I agree with the above posters, I can't vote for Python as my favorite *Programming* language?
I really don't think that this poll is very respectable.

buggywhip's picture

Python is....

On January 25th, 2008 buggywhip (not verified) says:

Python is a general purpose programming language!   It is interpreted as opposed to compiled.   It is dynamically typed as opposed to statically typed, but definitely strongly typed.   ...and back in the early 90s it may have been seen as a scripting language, but that moniker is no longer accurate.   It is a general purpose language from which the full range of applications can be built, and has been for quite some time now.

If you must differentiate, please do so on the basis of compiled vs interpreted, but today Python is no longer your father's scripting language.

I'm very puzzled to see "Microsystems" listed as an option under question #32. It is either a typo
and it was supposed to be "Sun Microsystems" or it is a company Google known nothing about. And we
all know Google can't be wrong.

William's picture

Why the distinction between programming & scripting languages?

On January 24th, 2008 William (not verified) says:

The survey has two categories of favorite languages. Not only is this a totally arbitrary distinction among languages, but the pre-populated choices aren't even consistent in honoring the distinction. For example, BASIC and Scheme are both interpreted (or at least can be). Other languages, including at least LISP, ADA, Python, and Haskell are languages which are defined by their grammar and syntax, and not by their implementations. In each, there are implementations which take a scripted/interpreted/bytecode approach, and other implementations which can compile down to native-processor machine code.

Also, asking 'what is your favorite security tool' and 'favorite sysadmin' tool is WAY too big of a category. Security and Systems Administration aren't a particular functions (as opposed to, say photo management, editor, or database). They are entire fields of endevour. Comparing how I like a tool such as Nessus to how I like a tool like IPTables in the security category is apples and oranges to the extreme. And how can you compare whether you prefer rsync over LDAP directories for sysadmin tools?

Finally, when the result of this survey actually gets written up, I would highly recommend an article that actually describes *each and every* option and write in suggestion. So often, I've read the 'Reader's choice awards' and read the description of the winning tool for the bazillionith time and I am constantly thinking to myself, the winning tool isn't the one that needs to get explained, it's the really valuable tool that got 1% of the votes because people don't know why it is so cool.

Anonymous's picture

Package manager and system administration tool

On January 24th, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

Where are urpmi and Mandriva control centre (mcc)?

Paddy3118's picture

No way to give Python as favourite programming language!

On January 24th, 2008 Paddy3118 (not verified) says:

All languages in the scripting category should be added to the programming language category if you must make the distinction, as this correctly highlights the lack of ability of the PL's in your current PL section 18.

- Paddy.

Anonymous's picture

Missing Option in #22 - Sun Studio Compilers & Tools

On January 23rd, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

In the "22. What is your favorite Linux software development tool?" question, there is a significant option that has been overlooked - Sun Studio software. Freely available on Solaris and Linux platforms, its optimizing compilers, source and memory debuggers, thread and performance analyzers, and IDE make a well integrated toolchain for C/C++/Fortran developers.

Anand's picture

No confirmation of submission?

On January 23rd, 2008 Anand (not verified) says:

After filling up the form, clicking submit just reloads the form, with no indication of success of failure completing the survey.

Why is that so?

czep's picture

None of the above

On January 23rd, 2008 czep (not verified) says:

There should be a "None of the above" or at least "Unsure" option for the questions in this survey. We may try to be everywhere all the time, but not every LJ reader will have experience with all categories!

hello's picture

Fluxbox is not a Desktop

On March 25th, 2008 hello (not verified) says:

Fluxbox is not a Desktop Environment. It's a Window Manager ;)

LIM's picture

Oh well

On January 24th, 2008 LIM (not verified) says:

where I had nothing I liked I checked Other : "none"

admin's picture

Ok to skip categories

On January 24th, 2008 admin says:

As the intro says, "it's also ok to skip voting in categories not applicable to you". The only field that must be filled in is email (so we can remove multiple votes from single email addresses).

Don't worry, we don't expect you to have an opinion on all of them. :)

JonP's picture

It's possible

On January 24th, 2008 JonP (not verified) says:

Where I did not have experience with the item, I checked "Other" and put in "Don't Use"

Anonymous's picture

Why was this entire form

On January 21st, 2008 Anonymous (not verified) says:

Why was this entire form included in the RSS feed?

esquiso's picture

Fluxbox is not a Desktop

On January 23rd, 2008 esquiso (not verified) says:

Fluxbox is not a Desktop Environment. It's a Window Manager ;)

Ozux's picture

FluxBox as Desktop environment

On February 1st, 2008 Ozux (not verified) says:

Hi,
I agree with you that FluxBox is not complete Desktop environment like GNOME or KDE or CDE, but you can use FluxBox or BlackBox and ... as your primary Desktop! Like what DSL Linux does, So in this voting we can assume Fluxbox as a Desktop mush as it's a WM.

Post new comment

Please note that comments may not appear immediately, so there is no need to repost your comment.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <pre> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Newsletter

Each week Linux Journal editors will tell you what's hot in the world of Linux. You will receive late breaking news, technical tips and tricks, and links to in-depth stories featured on www.linuxjournal.com.
Sign up for our Email Newsletter

Tech Tip Videos

From the Magazine

December 2009, #188

If last month's Infrastrucuture issue was too "big" for you then try on this month's Embedded issue. Find out how to use Player for programming mobile robots, build a humidity controller for your root cellar, find out how to reduce the boot time of your embedded system, and if you're new to embedded systems find out the basics that go into one. You can also read about the Beagle Board, the Mesh Potato and a spate of other interestingly named items. And along with our regular columns don't miss our new monthly column: Economy Size Geek.







Read this issue