Protecting SSH Servers with Single Packet Authorization
Suppose that the SPA packet from the first example above was sniffed off the wire en route by a crafty individual on the system labeled attacker in the network diagram in Figure 1. The SPA packet always can be placed back on the wire in an effort to gain the same access as the original packet—this is known as a replay attack. There are several ways to acquire the packet data and replay it. One of the most common is to use tcpdump to write a pcap file (in this case tcpdump -i eth0 -l -nn -s 0 -w SPA.pcap port 62201 would work) and then use tcpreplay (see tcpreplay.synfin.net/trac) to copy the SPA packet back onto the wire. Another method, after the packet has been captured, is to use the echo command along with netcat:
[attacker]$ echo "U2FsdGVkX1+BvzxXj5Zv6gvfCFXwJ+iJGKP \ qe2whdYzyigkerSp2WtvON/xTd8t6V6saxbg1v4zsK+YNt53BE8EI \ nxVCgpD7y/gEBIg8sd+AvU1ekQh9vwJJduseVx \ DxjmAHx3oNnClo2wckBqd8zA" |nc -u 22.214.171.124 62201
On the fwknopd server, the duplicate SPA packet is monitored, but because the MD5 sum matches that of the original SPA packet, no access is granted, and the following message is written to syslog on the spa_server system:
Feb 10 14:14:24 spa_server fwknopd: attempted \ message replay from: 126.96.36.199
Single Packet Authorization provides an additional layer of security for services such as SSHD, and this layer strikes at the first step that an attacker must accomplish when trying to compromise a system: reconnaissance. By using iptables in a default-drop stance and fwknop to sniff the wire for specially constructed (that is, encrypted and non-replayed) packets, it is difficult even to tell that a service is listening, let alone communicate with it. The end result is that it is significantly harder to exploit any vulnerabilities a protected service might have.
An excellent source of additional theoretical information about both port knocking and Single Packet Authorization can be found in Sebastien Jeanquier's Master's thesis at the Royal Holloway College, University of London. The thesis can be downloaded from web.mac.com/s.j, and it includes an excellent argument for why SPA is not “security through obscurity”.
The Rijndael cipher was selected in 2001 for the Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) as the successor to the aging Data Encryption Standard (DES). A good writeup can be found at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Encryption_Standard.
GnuPG is the GNU Privacy Guard, and is an open-source implementation of the OpenPGP standard. More information can be found at www.gnupg.org.
Michael Rash holds a Master's Degree in applied mathematics with a concentration in computer security from the University of Maryland. Michael is the founder of cipherdyne.org, a Web site dedicated to open-source security software for Linux systems, and he works as Security Architect on the Dragon Intrusion Detection System for Enterasys Networks. He is the author of the upcoming book Linux Firewalls: Attack Detection and Response, published by No Starch Press.
- diff -u: What's New in Kernel Development
- Download "Linux Management with Red Hat Satellite: Measuring Business Impact and ROI"
- Numerical Python
- Use Linux as a SAN Provider
- RSS Feeds
- Divx# Watch The Other Woman Full HD Online Streaming Viooz
- Linux-Based X Terminals with XDMCP
- Tech Tip: Really Simple HTTP Server with Python
- NSA: Linux Journal is an "extremist forum" and its readers get flagged for extra surveillance
- Great Scott! It's Version 13!