Choosing a GUI Library for Your Embedded Device
In this article, we look at two GUI libraries, examine the differences and give some advice on when to choose each.
The company I work for is dedicated to helping customers make the right decision about the technology they want to use in their embedded software development, and afterward it supports them in using the chosen technology. My specialty is embedded Linux.
Talking with customers, I see that more and more products need some sort of graphical display. So, I decided it was time to gain more knowledge about GUI development on embedded Linux.
The path I chose was the practical one. I did some research and found that the most common libraries are Qtopia (also known as Qt embedded) and Nano-X (formerly known as Microwindows).
The first solution is simply to implement some test app to demonstrate the two GUI libs. Such “test apps” only seldom resemble a real-world application, but I do this mostly because I am an engineer, and engineers are more interested in the technology beneath than in the appearance.
“Then why have an engineer test the libraries?”, you might ask. Well, think of GUI libraries as the technology to make an appearance. Therefore, you need both the technology view and the appearance view.
Another aspect of me doing this test is that I am not involved in any of the projects, and therefore I come with the knowledge that most other programmers have when they start out using the libraries. Some of my choices regarding the implementation probably are not optimal. They are made from the information available to the common user of the library—such as the problem with the scrolling graph, discussed below.
So, before ranting at me about how I could have done things differently, please look in the docs. Are they clear about the matter? If not, maybe it is better to change the docs instead.
I decided to get some external inspiration and went to the nearby university, where they have a department educating in User Centered Design (UCD). I asked one of the students, Esti Utami Handarini Povlsen (who was an old friend of mine), to come up with a GUI specification that I would then implement, using the two libraries. After having calibrated our technical language so we could communicate, we found a suitable design that I took to my home to implement.
The design that I got was for a Personal Mobile Medical Device (PMMD). The design consists of a single window with some static buttons and a changing display area showing text and/or graphs.
It turns out that the most challenging part is the heartbeat monitor graph, which is a varying line scrolling across the screen.
The platform I used for the evaluation is the MIPS32-based mb1100 from Mechatronic Brick. The mb1100 development kit is equipped with an AMD Alchemy au1100 CPU, a 6.5" TFT screen, an ADS7846E four-wire touch screen, 32MB of RAM and 32MB of Flash.
I started out with the Qtopia library. The creator of Qtopia is the Norwegian company Trolltech. Trolltech is mostly known for its Qt library on desktop computers; Qt is the base GUI of KDE. Qtopia is the embedded version of the Qt library.
Both Qt and Qtopia are dual-licensed, under the GPL and a commercial license. You can download the GPL version from the Trolltech Web site and use it as any other GPL library. This forces your Qt/Qtopia applications to go under the GPL too. You also can choose to buy the commercial license, which allows you to make closed source applications. The differences between the two versions are minor, if any, except of course for the licenses.
Qtopia can run directly on the framebuffer device, so make sure that the kernel is compiled with framebuffer support and that it is working.
That is the easy part. The difficult part is making the touch screen work. After having corrected a few glitches in the driver, I had a lot of trouble calibrating the device in Qtopia.
I am using Qtopia with tslib for the touch screen, and after having corrected the driver, tslib was working, and the little calibration program included in the tslib package calibrated well. Drawing lines with the pen in the same program worked fine. After starting a Qtopia program, the calibration was gone, and I tried the calibration program from the Qtopia package with no luck.
I found the error when looking in the sources of Qtopia and tslib. When tslib starts up, it looks into a file in /etc. This file tells tslib what modules to load, and those modules usually include the linearization module and different noise filters.
The linear module is the one that does the calibration. When looking in the sources of Qtopia, I found that the programmer wanted to make sure that the linear module was loaded, so after parsing the tslib config file, Qtopia loads the linear module, regardless of what is written in the config file. This means that if the linear module is defined in the config file, it is loaded twice, and this breaks the functionality. Having figured this out, I removed the linear module from the config file. (I know the correct solution would be to correct the Qtopia sources, but I took the shortcut.) Now the calibration worked in Qtopia.
- Let's Go to Mars with Martian Lander
- VMware's Clarity Design System
- Applied Expert Systems, Inc.'s CleverView for TCP/IP on Linux
- My Childhood in a Cigar Box
- Papa's Got a Brand New NAS
- Rogue Wave Software's TotalView for HPC and CodeDynamics
- Panther MPC, Inc.'s Panther Alpha
- Jetico's BestCrypt Container Encryption for Linux
- Simplenote, Simply Awesome!
- Smith Charts for All