Advanced MythTV Video Processing
Although digital TV recordings are an MPEG-2 video stream, the NuppelVideo container format used by MythTV is specific to MythTV and is not supported by most video player software. To watch the videos with anything other than a MythTV front end, you must convert them to a format with a wider selection of players.
Exporting video is further complicated by the filenames used by MythTV to store recordings. The first part of the filename is the channel number used by MythTV, and the two long numbers are the start date and end date:
myth:/video$ ls -lh *.nuv -rw-r--r-- 1 mythtv users 2.8G Sep 3 08:00 1000_20050903073000_20050903080000.nuv -rw-r--r-- 1 mythtv users 9.1G Aug 31 23:30 1007_20050831220000_20050831233000.nuv -rw-r--r-- 1 mythtv users 808M Sep 3 01:30 1008_20050903010000_20050903013000.nuv -rw-r--r-- 1 mythtv users 1.8G Sep 1 09:00 1009_20050901080000_20050901090000.nuv -rw-r--r-- 1 mythtv users 3.7G Aug 28 22:00 1019_20050828210000_20050828220000.nuv
Tools to convert the MythTV recordings into more widely supported formats are readily available. mythtranscode, a program that can decode the MythTV NuppelVideo files into a standard video stream supported by many programs, comes as part of the MythTV distribution. By feeding the output of mythtranscode to an encoder program of your choice, you can create any type of video file you want. A common choice of encoder program is FFmpeg, which supports many common video formats. Linking the two programs together to produce an intelligible output file is theoretically possible, but wading through all the command-line options and the recordings on your system is a complicated process.
Enter nuvexport, a Perl script that manages the process for you in an extremely friendly manner. nuvexport assembles the command-line options necessary to run mythtranscode and FFmpeg. It uses a text-based menu interface to guide you through the process of selecting a show for export and then setting up any required parameters of the conversion programs.
Before installing nuvexport, there are a few necessary support tools. FFmpeg is the default program required to re-encode the video into the selected target format. (nuvexport also supports transcode, which is much slower.) MPlayer is used to decode the MythTV files for conversion. Many conversions result in the appearance of noise that needs to be filtered out. nuvexport uses the yuvdenoise program, which is one of the MJPEG tools. All three programs are widely used and are likely to be available as packages for your Linux distribution. nuvexport uses the DateManip module as well, so fetch that from your distribution's package site or favorite CPAN mirror.
The first prompt from nuvexport is to select the format of the exported video file. The basic trade-off is whether to choose an MPEG-4-based export format for minimum file size at the cost of extra processing time to prepare it, or to use one of the larger but easier to prepare formats. The major choices are:
Video CD (VCD) consists of an MPEG-1 video stream at 1,150kbps, with the audio in a separate MPEG layer 2 (MP2) track at 224kbps.
Super Video CD (SVCD) consists of an MPEG-2 video at a variable rate, while retaining the MP2 audio track. Unlike VCD, the audio track can have multiple channels, so 5.1 or 7.1 audio can be stored in this format.
DVD is based on MPEG-2 video, with several options for an audio track. It is higher resolution than either of the video CD formats.
DivX is an MPEG-4-based format, which results in small files. However, it minimizes file size without significant sacrifices in quality. DivX can produce either constant-rate video or variable-rate video.
XviD is an MPEG-4-based format that is an offshoot of the development of DivX. It is based on an open-source development of a DivX codec released in 2001. By default, nuvexport uses variable-rate video encoding for XviD and offers the option of either a single pass or multiple passes. Multiple passes improve video quality at the expense of processing time.
Advanced Streaming Format (ASF) was developed by Microsoft as a generic container for media, and it is commonly used with Windows Media Audio (WMA) and Windows Media Video (WMV) files. WMV is based on Microsoft extensions to MPEG-4.
In my experience, the VCD and SVCD codecs offer good quality with fast processing times, while the DivX and XviD codecs offer the smallest file size but take longer to produce. After selecting a video export format, nuvexport uses a text-based menu system to select the episodes for export and set up parameters for the codec.
After selecting a set of episodes for export, nuvexport presents standard questions, such as where to put the exported file. It offers the option of using the MythTV cutlist, which cuts commercials from the exported video. Noise reduction and deinterlacing are offered as options. Although both default to yes, I usually disable them because of the additional processing time. Many video players can deinterlace on playback, and I have not found excessive noise from conversion.
Some export formats have additional codec-specific questions. Both DivX and XviD will allow adjustment of the bit rates and resolution. The default bit rates of 128kbps for audio and 960kbps for video are sufficient to produce good-quality video on most computer displays. When setting video size, nuvexport prompts for the width first and then proposes a height based on the aspect ratio of the recording. Keep the width less than the recorded width. The default width of 624 usually produces good video, but it can be larger for recordings that are 1920x1080. VCD and SVCD do not prompt for resolution because the formats have fixed resolutions.
Table 1 compares the processing time and space required by each of the different formats, as well as the MythTV native format and my commercial DVR. As a source, I used an hour-long episode of PBS's Nova, which is transmitted at a resolution of 704x480. The “commercial DVR” entry is for the video program as transferred from my commercial DVR to my laptop. As a rule of thumb, MPEG-2 requires approximately 1GB per hour, but MPEG-4 will be only 350–450MB. The encoding time listed in the table does not take into account either deinterlacing or noise reduction; I perform both tasks in the video player on playback.
Table 1. Results of Export (Typical)
|Format||Resolution||File size||Encoding time|
|Myth native format||704x480||1,756MB||N/A|
|XviD (1 pass)||624x464||451MB||1 hour, 39 min.|
|XviD (2 pass)||624x464||472MB||2 hours, 35 min.|
Although ASF has the smallest size, it is also by far the worst looking. There are large compression artifacts in the ASF file that make it very distracting to watch. Although the small size is attractive, the poor picture quality rules it out. DVD video has the best picture quality, but it also requires the most disk space. As a compromise between the two extremes, I use VCD and DivX, depending on priorities. I use the former to create a file quickly, and the latter to create the smallest file possible.
Video transcoding is a CPU-intensive process. By default, nuvexport runs its helper processes at high nice values to prevent them from interfering with other system operations, such as video playback or recording. All recent Linux distributions have software that allows the CPU clock speed to be changed in response to demand for processing power. I use the CPU speed control to keep the clock speed as low as possible while still accomplishing the work I want. Many CPU speed control programs will not take into account niced processes, but they can be configured to do so. My Linux distribution uses the CPUfreq kernel driver, which needs to be configured to monitor niced processes. A small start-up script runs the following two commands:
echo "ondemand" > /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor echo "1" > /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/ondemand/ignore_nice
The second command instructs CPUfreq driver to count the processing demands from niced processes. Times listed in Table 1 are from a 2.0GHz AMD Athlon64 running at top speed. At the minimum speed of 1.0GHz, processing time is approximately three to four times as long. Exporting the video from MythTV is only the first half of the battle. Once the video is produced, it can be transferred to another location for playback. In addition to the playback applications present on the viewing platform, there are two notable open-source playback applications: MPlayer and Video LAN Client (VLC). I use MPlayer because the built-in deinterlacing capabilities result in a smoother picture than VLC. Both applications are available on both Linux and Windows.
MPlayer's command line is identical on different host operating systems. The goal is to get crisp full-screen video playback. The -fs option plays back the video with the full screen so there is no window around the video. Video filters can be used to change the playback and are activated with the -vf option. I use two -vf options. One creates a small black border around the screen with the expand filter. The expand filter takes multiple arguments. A negative number is interpreted as a border. The filter -vf expand=0:-50 puts a 50-pixel border at the bottom of the screen and leaves the video centered in the border. To get crisp video, deinterlacing is necessary. MPlayer activates deinterlacing with the postprocessing filter, abbreviated pp. As a general rule, I turn on four postprocessing filters: horizontal de-blocking (hb), vertical de-blocking (vb), de-ringing (dr) and brightness/contrast correction (al). The resulting filter is activated with -vf pp=hb/vb/dr/al. Putting it all together, the command line is:
mplayer -fs -vf pp=hb/vb/dr/al -vf expand=0:-50 (filename)
During playback, MPlayer's extensive keyboard commands enable pausing, fast-forwarding and picture adjustment, as well as on-screen display.
Resources for this article: /article/8585.
Matthew Gast is the author of the leading technical book on wireless LANs, 802.11 Wireless Networks: The Definitive Guide (O'Reilly Media). He is currently spending far too much time these days working with MythTV. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org, but only when he is close to sea level.
- Let's Go to Mars with Martian Lander
- Applied Expert Systems, Inc.'s CleverView for TCP/IP on Linux
- My Childhood in a Cigar Box
- Returning Values from Bash Functions
- Papa's Got a Brand New NAS
- Tech Tip: Really Simple HTTP Server with Python
- Rogue Wave Software's TotalView for HPC and CodeDynamics
- GENIVI Alliance's GENIVI Vehicle Simulator
- Panther MPC, Inc.'s Panther Alpha