Distributed Caching with Memcached
LiveJournal.com currently has 28 Memcached instances running on our network on ten unique hosts, caching the most popular 30GB of data. Our hit rate is around 92%, which means we're hitting our databases a lot less often than before.
On our Web nodes with 4GB of memory, we run three Memcached instances of 1GB each, then mod_perl using 500MB, leaving 500MB of breathing room. Running Memcached on the same machine as mod_perl works well, because our mod_perl code is CPU-heavy, whereas Memcached hardly touches the CPU. Certainly, we could buy machines dedicated to Memcached, but we find it more economical to throw up Memcached instances wherever we happen to have extra memory and buy extra memory for any old machine that can take it.
You even can run a Memcached farm with all instances being different sizes. We run a mix of 512MB, 1GB and 2GB instances. You can specify the instances and their sizes in the client configuration, and the Memcached connection object weights appropriately.
Of course, the primary motivation for caching is speed, so Memcached is designed to be as fast as possible. The initial prototype of Memcached was written in Perl. Although I love Perl, the prototype was laughably slow and bloated. Perl trades off memory usage for everything, so a lot of precious memory was wasted, and Perl can't handle tons of network connections at once.
The current version is written in C as a single-process, single-threaded, asynchronous I/O, event-based dæmon. For portability and speed, we use libevent (see the on-line Resources section) for event notification. The advantage of libevent is that it picks the best available strategy for dealing with file descriptors at runtime. For example, it chooses kqueue on BSD and epoll on Linux 2.6, which are efficient when dealing with thousands of concurrent connections. On other systems, libevent falls back to the traditional poll and select methods.
Inside Memcached, all algorithms are O(1). That is, the runtime of the algorithms and CPU used never varies with the number of concurrent clients, at least when using kqueue or epoll, or with the size of the data or any other factor.
Of note, Memcached uses a slab allocator for memory allocation. Early versions of Memcached used the malloc from glibc and ended up falling on their faces after about a week, eating up a lot of CPU space due to address space fragmentation. A slab allocator allocates only large chunks of memory, slicing them up into little chunks for particular classes of items, then maintaining freelists for each class whenever an object is freed. See the Bonwick paper in Resources for more details. Memcached currently generates slab classes for all power-of-two sizes from 64 bytes to 1MB, and it allocates an object of the smallest size that can hold a submitted item. As a result of using a slab allocator, we can guarantee performance over any length of time. Indeed, we've had production Memcached servers up for 4–5 months at a time, averaging 7,000 queries/second, without problems and maintaining consistently low CPU usage.
Another key requirement for Memcached was that it be lockless. All objects are multiversioned internally and reference counted, so no client can block any other client's actions. If one client is updating an object stored in Memcached while a dozen others are downloading it, even with one client on a lossy network connection dropping half its packets, nobody has to wait for anybody else.
A final optimization worth noting is that the protocol allows fetching multiple keys at once. This is useful if your application knows it needs to load a few hundred keys. Instead of retrieving them all sequentially, which would take a fraction of a second in network round-trips, the application can fetch them all in one request. When necessary, the client libraries automatically split multi-key loads from the application into separate parallel multi-key loads to the Memcached instances. Alternatively, applications can provide explicit hash values with keys to keep groups of data on the same instance. That also saves the client library a bit of CPU time by not needing to calculate hash values.
The client/server interface to Memcached is simple and lightweight. As such, there are client libraries for Perl, PHP, Python and Java. I also hear that a coworker of mine has been working on a Ruby client, due out soon.
All of the clients support object serialization using their native serialization methods. Perl uses Storable, PHP uses serialize, Python uses Pickle and Java uses the Serializable interface. Most clients also support transparent compression, optionally only past a certain size threshold. Both serialization and compression are possible because Memcached lets client modules store opaque flags alongside stored items, indicating how they should handle the data coming out.
Practical books for the most technical people on the planet. Newly available books include:
- Agile Product Development by Ted Schmidt
- Improve Business Processes with an Enterprise Job Scheduler by Mike Diehl
- Finding Your Way: Mapping Your Network to Improve Manageability by Bill Childers
- DIY Commerce Site by Reven Lerner
Plus many more.
- diff -u: What's New in Kernel Development
- Server Hardening
- Giving Silos Their Due
- 22 Years of Linux Journal on One DVD - Now Available
- What's New in 3D Printing, Part III: the Software
- Controversy at the Linux Foundation
- Don't Burn Your Android Yet
- February 2016 Issue of Linux Journal
- Firefox OS