uClinux for Linux Programmers
uClinux has seen a huge increase in popularity and is appearing in more commodity devices than ever before. Its use in routers (Figure 1), Web cameras and even DVD players is testimony to its versatility. The explosion of low-cost, 32-bit CPUs capable of running uClinux is providing even more options to manufacturers considering uClinux. Now with uClinux's debut as part of the 2.6 kernel, it is set to become even more popular.
With more embedded developers facing the possibility of working with uClinux, a guide to its differences from Linux and its traps and pitfalls is an invaluable tool. Here we discuss the changes a developer might encounter when using uClinux and how the environment steers the development process.
The defining and most prevalent difference between uClinux and other Linux systems is the lack of memory management. Under Linux, memory management is achieved through the use of virtual memory (VM). uClinux was created for systems that do not support VM. As VM usually is implemented using a processing unit called an MMU (memory management unit), you often hear the term NOMMU when traveling in uClinux circles.
With VM, all processes run at the same address, albeit a virtual one, and the VM system takes care of what physical memory is mapped to these locations. So even though the virtual memory the process sees is contiguous, the physical memory it occupies can be scattered around. Some of it even may be on a hard disk in swap. Because arbitrarily located memory can be mapped to anywhere in the process' address space, it is possible to add memory to an already running process.
Without VM, each process must be located at a place in memory where it can be run. In the simplest case, this area of memory must be contiguous. Generally, it cannot be expanded as there may be other processes above and below it. This means that a process in uClinux cannot increase the size of its available memory at runtime as a traditional Linux process would.
Although all programs need to be relocated at run time so that they can execute, it is a fairly transparent task for the developer. It is the direct effect of no VM that is the thorn in every uClinux developer's side. The net effect is that no memory protection of any kind is offered—it is possible for any application or the kernel to corrupt any part of the system. Some CPU architectures allow certain I/O areas, instructions and memory regions to be protected from user programs but that is not guaranteed. Even worse than the corruption that crashes a system is the corruption that goes unnoticed, and tracking down random interprocess corruption can be extremely difficult.
Without VM, swap is effectively impossible, although this limitation is rarely an issue on the kinds of systems that run uClinux. They often do not have hard drives or enough memory to make swap worthwhile.
To a kernel developer, uClinux offers little in the way of differences from Linux. The only real issue is that you cannot take advantage of the paging support provided by an MMU. In practice, this doesn't affect much of the kernel. tmpfs, for example, does not work on uClinux because it relies on the VM system.
Similarly, all of the standard executable formats are unsupported, because they make use of VM features that do not exist under uClinux. Instead, a new format is required, the flat format. Flat format is a condensed executable format that stores only executable code and data, along with the relocations needed to load the executable into any location in memory.
Device drivers often need some work when you move to uClinux, not because of differences in the kernels, but due to the kinds of devices the kernel needs to support. For example, the SMC network driver supports ISA SMC cards. They usually are 16-bit and are located at I/O addresses below 0x3ff. The same driver easily can be made to support the non-ISA embedded versions of the chip, but it may need to run in 8-, 16- or 32-bit mode, at an I/O address that is a full 32-bit address and at an interrupt number quite often higher than ISA's maximum of 16. So despite the fact that the bulk of the driver is the same, the hardware specifics can require a little porting effort. Quite often, older drivers store I/O addresses in short format, which does not work on an embedded uClinux platform with devices appearing at memory-mapped I/O addresses.
The implementation of mmap within the kernel is also quite different. Though often transparent to the developer, it needs to be understood so it is not used in ways that are particularly inefficient on uClinux systems. Unless the uClinux mmap can point directly to the file within the filesystem, thereby guaranteeing that it is sequential and contiguous, it must allocate memory and copy the data into the allocated memory. The ingredients for efficient mmap usage under uClinux are quite specific. First, the only filesystem that currently guarantees that files are stored contiguously is romfs. So one must use romfs to avoid the allocation. Second, only read-only mappings can be shared, which means a mapping must be read-only in order to avoid the allocation of memory. The developer under uClinux cannot take advantage of copy-on-write features for this reason. The kernel also must consider the filesystem to be “in ROM”, which means a nominally read-only area within the CPU's address space. This is possible if the filesystem is present somewhere in RAM or ROM, both of which are addressable directly by the CPU. One cannot have a zero allocation mmap if the filesystem is on a hard disk, even if it is a romfs filesystem, as the contents are not directly addressable by the CPU.
|Privacy Is Personal||Jul 02, 2015|
|July 2015 Issue of Linux Journal: Mobile||Jul 01, 2015|
|July 2015 Video Preview||Jul 01, 2015|
|PHP for Non-Developers||Jun 30, 2015|
|A Code Boot Camp for Underprivileged Kids||Jun 30, 2015|
|Comprehensive Identity Management and Audit for Red Hat Enterprise Linux||Jun 29, 2015|
- July 2015 Issue of Linux Journal: Mobile
- PHP for Non-Developers
- Secure Server Deployments in Hostile Territory
- Linux Kernel 4.1 Released
- Privacy Is Personal
- A Code Boot Camp for Underprivileged Kids
- Django Templates
- Comprehensive Identity Management and Audit for Red Hat Enterprise Linux
- Cinnamon 2.6 Released
- Attack of the Drones