Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

If you're in the market for a new laptop, here's some advice to consider before you spend the money.
To Pay for Windows or Not to Pay for Windows?

This question is a loaded issue in the portable Linux community. When you build a standard desktop the issue doesn't arise. You buy each component independently, so there is no Microsoft-enslaved reseller watching over you. Due to the general proprietary nature of laptops, however, in many cases you have no choice but to deal with a reseller (as most major manufacturers are resellers) and, in turn, purchase a Microsoft-based OS. Stories are going around that you can call the laptop manufacturer itself and specifically request to have them ship you a system free of Microsoft OSes. In turn, you save the cost of the licensing fee. I personally have tried this tactic and to no avail; both IBM and Dell turned down the idea. This may be a major issue for the die-hard users, but I think most people don't get hung up on the idea of buying something they are never going to use. Keep in mind that the resellers are selling Windows at their discounted rate. In some cases the rate is as cheap as $15. So unless you can't stand the thought of Redmond getting your undeserved cash, I wouldn't put much thought into the issue. Yes, it sucks, but unfortunately its a necessary evil.

So You Found Your Dream Laptop

You found it, and now you're trying to find it for the best price. This is the final hurdle to your life in portable-Linux nirvana. You have four main choices, a walk-in retail store, an on-line retail store, the laptop manufacturer itself or an auction site. Browse the auction sites to get a ball-park figure of what people are willing to spend. If the system you want is going for over retail cost, you can be sure it is a high quality product and in demand. In my experience, though, I wouldn't recommend making that final purchase through an auction site. Not only is your purchase not warrantied in any way, there is a good chance that you could be paying too much. For example, I recently purchased a laptop directly from its manufacturer for $1,500. Later that evening the same exact laptop was sold on eBay for $2,100. People often get caught up in the frenzy of bidding and don't take the time to research where the best buy can be found. If it's available, I suggest purchasing directly from the manufacturer. Some manufacturers, such as HP/Compaq, do not sell certain lines of laptops through their site and refer you to an outside retail store. The biggest advantage of a walk-in store is the immediate satisfaction. Or, if you have any initial problems with the laptop, you can return it without having to worry about RMAs and extra shipping costs.

The last major item of concern is one that can be easily overlooked—return policies. The return policy is your safety net to protect you from spending your days with an ugly stepson of a laptop. Let's say you finally get your laptop in hand and installed. Then, for some reason beyond your control, you find that whenever you close the lid X crashes. You've checked the newsgroups and forums, but no one can help you. This may be a good time to cut your losses, make the return and go back to the drawing board. Many manufacturers have 30-day, ”satisfaction guaranteed", money-back return policies. It's common place that retail outlets, whether walk-in or on-line, have 14-day return policies. An eBay purchase, for the most part, has no warranty. Be sure to take this all into account when dropping that last coin.

Remember, as with any purchase, knowledge is your friend. A hasty purchase could lead you to hours of headaches down the road. A big issue I had when making my recent laptop purchase was the overall cost. I went into it wanting to spend $500 and in the end spent $1,500. I paid for those extra nine yards to be sure that my purchase was money well spent on a machine that I could rely on for years to come. I was fortunate enough to have a flexible budget, but if you're stuck with a certain dollar amount, be sure to do plenty of research. And don't forget to have fun!

______________________

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Intro

Ella's picture

Pretty informative........thanks for the information. Need hard drive? Check http://www.allpartssource.com/index.php/hard-drives/notebook-drives/hita... wishes to all of you.

I agree withe him

Anonymous's picture

Sorry dudes, but I agree with the guy that says the article is useless coz it is. I do a search to learn something and I run into an article that says do more research ???? What's the point of the damn article?????? Nothing.

PRETEND you didn't know everything

Anonymous's picture

PRETEND you are new to Linux. PRETEND, just like I'm PRETENDING to be civil.

Linux for Compaq Presario V6102AU

Balaji's picture

I have purchased the Compaq Presario V6102AU. I hadn't checked if it would be compatible with RedHat Linux. I have a RedHat Linux 9.0 with me and I wanted to install it in this. Initially I thought it wouldn't detect the graphics card since nVIDIA gives closed source drivers. But it used a generic display setting and went ahead. The problem however was my hard disk. Anaconda exited saying that it could not detect any hard disks in my machine. I have a 100GB SATA hard drive.

If this version of Linux does not support it, which version do I have to go for? Please help me with this.

check the bios

Anonymous's picture

you can often set the sata drive to act like a ata drive in the bios. my low end presario supports this, so it's probably safe to assume most other laptops do also.

- hope that helps.

linux compatibility with sata hard disk

sanjudon's picture

my computer is compaq presario
speed=3.07ghz
sata harddisk 160gb
can i load linux in my computer

SATA drives and RH9

Lnuxius's picture

My friend, try UBUNTU 6.05; also known as Dapper Drake. I too attempted to load RH9 on a SONY Vaio S4XP.It would not load, and why? The kernel could not see a SATA drive-, it was actually looking for an IDE drive.

What you'll find is that later distros have the capability of configuring later devices. I loved RH9 while I used it. Ubuntu satisfies my everyday computing needs and mounts USB key drives etc on insertion. There's still no mp3 or mp4 support however. Its Ogg Vorbis for compressed audio and Ogg-Theora for film. But it installed on my Sony Vaio S4xp and Toshiba P20-801 with almost no issues at all! Impressive. Also check the web for linux compatible laptops.

problem with SATA HDD.

anis_huq's picture

I am having problems in installing Red Hat Linux 9.0 on my SATA HDD of 120 GB. Linux can't seem detect any HDD.

reply V6102AU

martin's picture

Fedora Core 5 (AMD64)
Ubuntu 6.06 (AMD64)
Gentoo Linux (AMD64)

i too purchased compaq V6102AU recently i suppose the following linux flavours would be supported!. I havent tried installing linux yet.
for more info pls visit http://www.linuxcertified.com/linux-laptop-lc2464t.html

Regards Martin
----------------------------------------------------

Please give advice for AIX laptops

Abhishek Joshi's picture

Dear All,

Any one knows about AIX compatible laptops.

Abhishek

Linuxcertified's laptop

Anonymous's picture

Consider getting a linuxcertified laptop (http://www.linuxcertified.com/). I have been fairly happy with mine.

Re: Buying LINUX Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I just want to say to the editor, we all know how to choose a laptop and what’s our budget to spent on the system, so, it will be much easier for you to do a little research and give us exact model number that will be fully compatible to LINUX of each brand instead of just write out the whole article of what your personal interest is and no useful information! Remember, every one can write the article like that, so, please do not waste readers time by going into some baby stuff such as, do you need to watch DVD on the laptop? How much money do I spent on my new computer..., and explain the retun policy of the store!#$? Every one know the return policy, we can read it on the back of the receipt, thanks!

If you don't like the

Anonymous's picture

If you don't like the content of the article then don't read it. Why don't you try writing the article you describe in you're well written request?

You don't know if an article

Anonymous's picture

You don't know if an article is useful until after you read it. Only then can you know it was a waste of time.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

don't buy toshiba portege 3480CT as it won't boot with knoppix,phlak,morphix and other distros

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

Does anyone have any comments about portables from Los Alamos Computer?
http://www.laclinux.com/en/Laptop

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I am considering buying a used Compaq Armada 1571:
Intel 200MHz processor with MMX
3.0 GB hard drive
1.44 floppy + 20x CD-ROM drives
serial & USB ports
SoundBlaster soundcard
Internal 56K modem

Distro: Libranet 2.8.1

Would welcome comments from anyone familiar with this model. It is almost certain that the modem will have to be replaced as it is probably a Winmodem and that is fine with me. The soundcard and my printer are supported by Libranet. TIA

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

You can test the linux compatibility by booting the laptop with knoppix, which supports a lot of hardware.

Doing so , you will know instantly if there is z good compatibility without spending hours in configuring things.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

Even better than a big name's labtop, i advice a labtop with Linux pre-installed. There are not a lot of them available through the web, but there are some, -- like mine -- and it's the easiest choice.

various options

Anonymous's picture

The other option would be to buy a refurbished laptop, quite inexpensive, running linux from various vendors, e.g. linuxcertified.com

Auction possibility

rknop's picture

If you don't need the latest and greatest laptop, you can find two-year-old models on eBay for a decent price sometimes. There are some advantages to this. First, chances are better that everything will be supported. (You're less likely to find a 3d video card, though, if that's what you need.) Second, you're much more likely to find several sites on the web where folks have gotten Linux working on that model. Third, even if it has Windows on it, at least you can rest confident that Microsoft isn't getting any money off of you.

And, of course, the cost can be quite a lot lower than it would be to purchase an acceptable laptop today. You do have to be careful to set your own limit and stick with it, and be a little patient to let a few go by until you get the one you want at the price you want. If you're realistic, it can be done.

I recently purchased an IBM Thinkpad X20 off of eBay, and am very happy with it. My "must-have" criterea were (1) good Linux support, (2) 1024x768 screen, and (3) very light. I didn't need a ultrafast processor, or 3d acceleration (although the X20 has an ATI card which might work with an experimental DRI driver; I haven't tried it). With new laptops, (3) in particular means that one has to pay a premium, and given that I didn't really need the latest and greatest, it made sense to get an older one. I use the laptop to take notes on the road, to hook into the net on the road, to show OpenOffice.org presentations and (occasionally) movies/animations to a class. The 600MHz processor in the X20 is more than adequate for this, as is the hard drive. And, a couple of years ago, I'd installed and ran Linux on a couple of X20's at work, so I knew first hand that it would run well-- though there were plenty of sites on the web assuring me of that.

-Rob

Dell Laptops

Anonymous's picture

I have to say that Dell laptops are very good in their Linux support, as far as I know. I have an older Inspiron 8000 and everything works perfectly (except the Winmodem, but I could probably get that working if I had the time). Dell even has some support downloads for Red Hat Linux. I reccommend at least looking at Dell laptops for your next laptop. People say that video cards are the hardest things to have Linux support for on a laptop but Dell has either ATI or NVIDIA cards in all of their laptops, so this shouldn't be too much trouble.

Re: Dell Laptops

Anonymous's picture

I bought a Dell Inspiron 4000 with RH 7.0 installed by Dell. The modem was a PCMCIA card. It worked perfectly. I next bought a refurbished Dell Latitude C600 with Win 98 installed. This turned out to have the full 3 year next day on-site warrantee. Because win 98 was not current, Dell sold me the laptop for about $700 less than I paid for the Inspiron. My point: buy refurbished from Dell with the most obsolete Windows OS you can find. Then either use PartitionMagic and add Linux, or install Linux over Windows. I swaped out the original 10GB HD and put in a 20GB HD. I installed RH 8.0, RH 7.3, Mdk 8.2 and Slack 8.1 each in a 5 GB partition. Don't try using lilo to boot (although it can be done) use grub as bootloader (if you're dual booting).

Re: Dell Laptops

Anonymous's picture

I bought a refurbished Dell Latitude C600 laptop on eBay. 20 gig HD (empty), 750mHz CPU, CD and 3.5" floppy drives, 512 meg RAM (I'd upgraded from the 128meg it was offered with), 14.1" TFT screen. I bought a Lucent WiFi card for it, it came with a Xircom combo 56k modem and10/100 ethernet card.

I installed RH 8.0 on it no problemo. I'm not savvy enough to be able to set up the WiFi or ethernet stuff yet (I'm working on that now). My point is, six months ago this was a top-of-the-line laptop. Today it's avail on eBay for 'prox $500 -- ok so I've more invested in mine, but the total is STILL under $1000 (even with all the extras for it I've bought). And it runs Linux -- beautifully.

Re: Dell Laptops

Anonymous's picture

I agree. I have an inspiron 4100 and everything that I use works - 1400x1050 resolution on the ATI card, sound card, network. I have previously had experience with a 3200, 5000 and an 8200 also. All filled my needs with a few minor quirks. The only one that I've heard to be problematic is the M50 / Latitude C840. My colleague could not get 1600x1200 to work on either of those. 1400x1050 worked fine though.

Closed drivers == upgrade disaster.

Anonymous's picture

The biggest problem with closed source drivers with GNU/Linux

is that it means that when you upgrade, you may lose the capability.

In some cases that isn't QUITE as likely with X-windows 4,

because they try to support some binary capability, but it's

still a problem (ESPECIALLY for drivers that directly hook into the

Linux kernel).

About IBM and Linux

Anonymous's picture

I recently checked IBM's web site to see if I could buy a Linux laptop from them. To my surprise, they recommended either Windows 2000 or XP to customers. By ''recommended'', I mean ''didn't offer any other choice''. That is coming from a company that boasts about the revenues it gets from selling Linux servers.

I think that IBM and all the other big vendors should get their act straight : either they allow people to choose which OS they're going to use or they publicly say that they are just testing waters (but are afraid of Microsoft).

I know that before PCs get out of factories, they are tested to see whether they will function properly with Windows. As others have said, how hard is it for computers manufacturers to have copies of a Live CD OS (Knoppix, Demolinux, FreeBSD Live, ...) that would make sure that their hardware is supported ?

Re: About IBM and Linux

Anbu's picture

I know Fujitsu used to test their products for Linux compatibility mainly with video as I was told by my friend who was working on those projects in India!

Re: About IBM and Linux

Anonymous's picture

keyword: servers

does not mean that ibm think linux is viable (for them) on the desktop yet.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I'm actually looking for the lightest, cheapest linux laptop I can find -- and I'm not planning to run X on it, so it can actually be fairly slow and old -- and recommendations for a tiny, barebones laptop?

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

eBay

IBM ThinkPad 600X

If you change your mind and want to run X, it will do that just fine.

Only downside is battery life (as with any pc laptop).

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

My Toshiba Libretto CT110 runs Linux without a problem and is tiny. My other laptop is a IBM T20 with a 13" screen and runs linux beautifully. If you want tiny go for the Libretto - it's the size of a VHS video cassette. If you want fully funcutional and 5lb light go for a IBM T20,21,22,23 or IBM Thinkpad 600e.

CT100

nick's picture

Do you by any chance have the original installation discs for your CT110 - mine are missing and the machine needs a complete rebuild

Thanks

ct110

yvon's picture

I am in the same situation, I have a ct110 with pcmcia cdrom from PORT
pcmcia ethernet card 3com.The toshiba win98 manual .
It crash, I found the way to reformat the disk but I don't have the original boot disk and CD.

I woul realy appreciate your help, if you got the info.

thank you

More info on 'Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop'

neovada's picture

Please expand, did you install SUSe linux 9.x on the IBM thinkpad T20?

I happen to have a problem, it seems with the microsoft usb scroll-bar mouse---it hangs the system all the time.
Should I use a ps/2 mouse?
Or can I adjust a unix software tweak in the system for this?

Glad to hear from you soon,
Thanks.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

Well, the Lindows MobilePC sounds like it might fit your bill:

http://info.lindows.com/mobilepc/mobilepc.htm

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I've got 2 Toshiba Porteges 320CT with docking stations & 96MB RAM & 4GB harddrive.Great little laptops.

I DO NOT care about sound and DO NOT need a Winmodem. I've loaded RH 7.1 & 8.0 without a problem. PCMCIA NIC, USB mouse work fine...Portege has a slightly odd screen dimension so a bit of hand work required in the Xconfig file but that was all...RH flawlessly finds the CDROM & floppy drive when docked...

Use Knoppix to test-drive the system

Anonymous's picture

The Knoppix bootable CD with a full desktop Linux system on it: http://www.knopper.net/knoppix/index-en.html That's 1200+ packages and 2GB of applications and data. Test drive your candidate systems with this.

If the system doesn't come up clean and fast with full video, audio, network, disk, PCMCIA, USB, and/or support for any other devices and baubles the system touts, explain to the salesdroid why you're walking away from it (tell the manufacturer as well), and try another system.

And manufacturers, if you're reading this, andand are wondering how to satisfy your Linux customers who would prefer to perform their own installation, but want to be assured of Linux compatibility, two suggestions:

  • Boot your systems on Knoppix. If they come up and are fully functional (video, sound, networking, USB, PCMCIA, modem, disk), then you're Linux friendly.
  • Run the "system-info" script from http://twiki.iwethey.org/twiki/bin/view/Main/LinuxSystemInfoScript and include its output as an informational file among system documents (along with the other useless information you're inclined to put on CDROMs and/or floppy disks).

Those two simple steps will address 99% of the concerns Linux users have when considering new laptops.

Karsten M. Self (kmself@ix.netcom.com)

Re: Use Knoppix to test-drive the system

Anonymous's picture

On my Toshiba Notebook (which is one year old), Linux works very well, but to use Knoppix, you have to set the "noscsi" boot parameter, otherwise it hangs during startup. So while the Knoppix test is generally a good idea, you should know the "Knoppix cheat codes" to avoid getting stuck in unnecessary hardware detection.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

If you REALLY want to know about GNU/Linux compatible laptops check: http://www.linux-laptop.net.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

And see the Linux-Mobile-Guide http://tuxmobil.org/howtos.html.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I think the article misses one sore point of linux laptoping of today. That is thermal and power management. Older laptops usually adhere to the APM-standard, which is quite well supported in linux today, and therefore those laptops generally work quite good. However newer laptops implements ACPI, which is another way of doing thermal and power management. Due to many manufacturers bad implementation of ACPI in ther bioses, many laptops won't work as intended when used with linux.

The one thing I have missed most from using linux on newer laptops is the ability for processors to change frequence on demand. Intel calls this technique speedstep and it drastically reduces power requirements of the processor.

I think this is very important, because of the smaller current needed. This implies longer battery-time, and maybe even more important, makes the fan of the system a lot quiteter since it doesn't have to run all the time.

In my system, a compaq laptop with 1.6 ghz processor I get about 4 hours of battery-time and a very quiet computer, when used with Windows XP and "light" computing like typing and so on. That is what I do most of the time, and the processor then drops to 1.2 ghz. In linux, the processor is always on 1.6 ghz and battery time drops to 2.5 hours. The fan is also on all the time.

All in all, my advice for people wanting to buy a new laptop for use with linux, is therefore to buy a computer which supports APM, or if ACPI is the only alternative, check if the manufacturer is known to support the standards. I know that compaq is not...

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

See lwn and Con's patch page for CPU frequency scaling kernel support. 2.4.21-ck3 includes preemptible kernel, low latency stuff, O(1) scheduler, ACPI, XFS, grsecurity; tons of good stuff for workstations.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

This is true. I did a lot of research before buying my laptop. But with all the research it still doesn't talk about ACPI and bios shortcomings. Fortunately for me my laptop is pretty well supported. Speedstep actually works on my machine. When I run off the battery it runs at 1.2 Ghz. When I am on AC it runs at the full 1.8 Ghz. I think it works too well. My whole computer slows down. The sound slows down the hard drive. So it is not perfect. I have even used a newer kernel and recompiled and it still is not perfect. But it works. I'm happy. I'm sure in the near future these things will be worked out. I have a VPR Matrix 180B5. It is actually a Samsung laptop rebadged and sold under BestBuy.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I've been looking at the vpr Matrix models from BestBuy. Several years ago I swore that I would never buy another computer from BestBuy, but these are sweet and priced very right. I looked around, downloaded windows drivers to find out exact hardware and it would seem everything is supported.

Quick features:

* 2.0GHz Intel

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I have the VPR Matrix 180b5 and am happily running Mandrake 9.0 on it. Everything installed and ran out of the box. The onlu exceptions are the winmodem and ACPI does not work either. But other than that it runs great. I'm pretty much running a cooker install so as far as Mandrake 9.1 support it should be just fine. Just follow the Linux How-to and you should be fine.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

I have one and I really like it. I've installed Gentoo and have X and wireless working beautifully. I'm having a little trouble with KDE misunderstanding my keyboard (it thinks that I always have the fn key down), but that should be fixable. I recommend this laptop, especially with all the deals best buy is offering right now.

Re: Watch the distribution!

Anonymous's picture

One further note: be sure you get a new distribution of Linux, whichever flavor you prefer. If you don't buy the latest, greatest, most expensive laptop, but do buy the latest and greatest Redhat/Suse or whatever, there's a much better chance that the distribution has worked out a lot of problems for you. Sure, you can spend hours, weeks, or months having the satisfaction of working out all those niggling bugs. But you could also slap the CDs or DVD in, install it, and run.

Re: Advice for Buying a Linux-Compatible Laptop

Anonymous's picture

If you believe *ANYTHING* the manufaturers say in terms of Linux driver support, you deserve to lose your money!

Download a KNOPPIX boot disk, go to a store with a good selection and ask to boot the model of your choice into Linux.

If it boots into X with a specific driver and autoconfigures the USB, wireless card etc. then you can be 100% sure that Mandrake, Debian, Redhat etc. will install without difficulty.

Don't be a sucker, try before you buy!

White Paper
Linux Management with Red Hat Satellite: Measuring Business Impact and ROI

Linux has become a key foundation for supporting today's rapidly growing IT environments. Linux is being used to deploy business applications and databases, trading on its reputation as a low-cost operating environment. For many IT organizations, Linux is a mainstay for deploying Web servers and has evolved from handling basic file, print, and utility workloads to running mission-critical applications and databases, physically, virtually, and in the cloud. As Linux grows in importance in terms of value to the business, managing Linux environments to high standards of service quality — availability, security, and performance — becomes an essential requirement for business success.

Learn More

Sponsored by Red Hat

White Paper
Private PaaS for the Agile Enterprise

If you already use virtualized infrastructure, you are well on your way to leveraging the power of the cloud. Virtualization offers the promise of limitless resources, but how do you manage that scalability when your DevOps team doesn’t scale? In today’s hypercompetitive markets, fast results can make a difference between leading the pack vs. obsolescence. Organizations need more benefits from cloud computing than just raw resources. They need agility, flexibility, convenience, ROI, and control.

Stackato private Platform-as-a-Service technology from ActiveState extends your private cloud infrastructure by creating a private PaaS to provide on-demand availability, flexibility, control, and ultimately, faster time-to-market for your enterprise.

Learn More

Sponsored by ActiveState