Open Letter to SourceForge
While I had not noticed this at first, it has come to my awareness that VA is now appending advertising to SourceForge project mailing lists. Advertising is certainly nothing new at SourceForge, as there are annoying banner ads, and consequentially for this reason, and because SourceForge is no longer being developed as free software, I have largely withdrawn from using it, except principally to continue hosting pre-existing mailing lists using your "mailman" list server.
However, I find this new use of mailing lists for stealth advertising both unethical and offensive, because they appear as if they were signature lines placed by the original poster. It is neither clear that the advertised products or services are not being endorsed and promoted by the message poster himself, nor is that any better than spamming unsuspecting users with unwanted junk e-mail, which is an equally disgusting practice. It is also perturbing to consider that such lists may be used to advertise proprietary software or potentially other products or services of similarly questionable ethical character.
Certainly I am free as a developer to terminate the use of any remaining services hosted by VA, and under these present intolerable circumstances, I see no choice but to do this. If there is no satisfactory response to this present situation, I am prepared to immediately close these remaining lists and request [that] any current projects I still have shown on SourceForge be de-listed. Fortunately, we do have several lists already available on gnu.org, and it would not take that long to merge the existing SourceForge list memberships into those with fairly minimal disruption. We also have an excellent system in place for free software development using Savannah.
My hope is that VA would reconsider some of it's recent policies and practices. I believe everyone would like to see SourceForge continue to be available and used as a developer community resource. I also fully appreciate the need VA has for finding some revenue model to continue providing SourceForge as a resource. However, I do not believe these specific practices will make this possible.
David SugarGNU Maintainer
I just saw your email(s). I've been on vacation during the past week and the pile of unread emails was sky high when I returned.
About ~45 days ago we started to put 2 line text messages at the bottom of SourceForge.net mailing lists.
As you probably know, running a site with over 3 million page views a day, 300,000 downloaded files a day, 700,000 emails a day, 80 servers, and a staff of people is very expensive.
We are using the email text messages, like many other sites, as a small way to offset some of the costs of running SourceForge.net for the Open Source Community.
Since the inception of these text messages, we have received very few complaints. I think the number is less than 10, which is pretty good considering we send out over 700,000 emails a day.
I think the reason why the complaints are so low is:
A) We told people about it before we did it. It was listed on the site prior to us going live.
B) Every email has the same ad. We change it approx once a week. Anyone getting more then one email can see that the ads are consistent and hence not part of the sig of the user.
C) The ads are not archived with the email when they are stored on the site for others to see on SF.NET. We strip out the ads to cut down on confusion.
D) Two lines of text is very consistent with what other sites are doing. At the bottom of the email it doesn't get in the way of the actual message.
Of the 10 people who have written us so far, you are the first to bring up the "stealth advertising" discussion. I understand what you are saying, but I haven't seen evidence from the feedback we've been getting that users are confused [by] what is an ad and what is a sig. Certainly there is no stealth intent from either us or our advertisers.
One thing we could possibly do is change the top delimiter from dashes to something like "Sponsored by:". It might help. I'll discuss it with the staff.
Thank you for the feedback. If you have any other questions/concerns please feel free to email me.
Editors' Note: David Sugar is the leader of the Bayonne Project, and Patrick McGovern is the site director for SourceForge.net. For more information about Savannah, visit the Savannah project web site and read the March 2002 UpFront column in LJ.
|Designing Electronics with Linux||May 22, 2013|
|Dynamic DNS—an Object Lesson in Problem Solving||May 21, 2013|
|Using Salt Stack and Vagrant for Drupal Development||May 20, 2013|
|Making Linux and Android Get Along (It's Not as Hard as It Sounds)||May 16, 2013|
|Drupal Is a Framework: Why Everyone Needs to Understand This||May 15, 2013|
|Home, My Backup Data Center||May 13, 2013|
- New Products
- Linux Systems Administrator
- Senior Perl Developer
- Technical Support Rep
- UX Designer
- Designing Electronics with Linux
- Dynamic DNS—an Object Lesson in Problem Solving
- Making Linux and Android Get Along (It's Not as Hard as It Sounds)
- Using Salt Stack and Vagrant for Drupal Development
- Nice article, thanks for the
8 hours 7 min ago
- I once had a better way I
13 hours 53 min ago
- Not only you I too assumed
14 hours 11 min ago
- another very interesting
16 hours 4 min ago
- Reply to comment | Linux Journal
17 hours 57 min ago
- Reply to comment | Linux Journal
1 day 51 min ago
- Reply to comment | Linux Journal
1 day 1 hour ago
- Favorite (and easily brute-forced) pw's
1 day 2 hours ago
- Have you tried Boxen? It's a
1 day 8 hours ago
- seo services in india
1 day 13 hours ago
Enter to Win an Adafruit Pi Cobbler Breakout Kit for Raspberry Pi
It's Raspberry Pi month at Linux Journal. Each week in May, Adafruit will be giving away a Pi-related prize to a lucky, randomly drawn LJ reader. Winners will be announced weekly.
Fill out the fields below to enter to win this week's prize-- a Pi Cobbler Breakout Kit for Raspberry Pi.
Congratulations to our winners so far:
- 5-8-13, Pi Starter Pack: Jack Davis
- 5-15-13, Pi Model B 512MB RAM: Patrick Dunn
- 5-21-13, Prototyping Pi Plate Kit: Philip Kirby
- Next winner announced on 5-27-13!
Free Webinar: Hadoop
How to Build an Optimal Hadoop Cluster to Store and Maintain Unlimited Amounts of Data Using Microservers
Realizing the promise of Apache® Hadoop® requires the effective deployment of compute, memory, storage and networking to achieve optimal results. With its flexibility and multitude of options, it is easy to over or under provision the server infrastructure, resulting in poor performance and high TCO. Join us for an in depth, technical discussion with industry experts from leading Hadoop and server companies who will provide insights into the key considerations for designing and deploying an optimal Hadoop cluster.
Some of key questions to be discussed are:
- What is the “typical” Hadoop cluster and what should be installed on the different machine types?
- Why should you consider the typical workload patterns when making your hardware decisions?
- Are all microservers created equal for Hadoop deployments?
- How do I plan for expansion if I require more compute, memory, storage or networking?