The Linux Position
For most of my adult life I have been two things: a journalist and a marketing expert. Frankly, I did the latter mostly to sublimate the former. This made me a very different kind of marketing expert—one who brought a writer's skepticism to the marketer's job. At every meeting, I always seemed to be asking the same two questions: what is this and what's the story?
Most companies—especially those in the technology world—are not interested in simple answers to simple questions. They make “solutions” rather than products and “management inference engines” rather than spreadsheets. They also want their stories to consist entirely of happy beginnings.
“Reporters write stories,” I would say, “and stories don't start with happily ever after. They start with a character with a problem. The solution comes at the end, and you never want to get there or the writer will find some other story to tell.”
I didn't get very far with this approach. What got me somewhere was working on the character issue. I called this “positioning” and I wasn't alone.
Hotbot finds 233,780 pages on the Web with the word “positioning” in them. When I weed out GPS and other non-marketing meanings, I get 26,940 pages, almost entirely by marketing consultancies selling “strategic distribution analysis”, “rollout plan reviews”, “campaign launch programs”, “performance impact studies”, “collateral market options”, “market penetration analyses”, “outsourced staff deployments” and other such nonsense, all served up in euphemistically delusional language.
No wonder Linux is a hit. It is a character with a story none of those 27,000 agencies—including mine—could have thought up. Who would seriously talk about “world domination” and “software that doesn't suck” in the face of Microsoft, whose software runs on every computer you see and whose market value exceeds the GNP of the Southern Hemisphere? “You see, there was this Finnish guy, and something about a penguin...” I don't think so.
Thus, what we have with Linux is more than the world's first big-time open-source operating system. We have the world's first marketing success that owes nothing to marketing. This warrants further study.
I just did for Linux what I used to do for my clients. I took a look at how the customers for Linux's message—the analysts, reporters and editors of the world—are describing its character and telling its story. I got on AltaVista (http://www.altavista.com/) and looked up every page with the phrase “Linux is...” and found over 27,000. Searching through links to the first fifty, I came up with these answers, which I sort into four ways of depicting Linux's character:
an open-source UNIX clone
a freely available UNIX clone
a UNIX clone
a complete, copylefted UN*X clone
a freely distributable, independent UNIX-like operating system
a UNIX-type 32-bit operating system
an operating system developed under the GNU General Public License
an open-source operating system anyone can download from the Internet and compile
a freeware version of UNIX
a true 32-bit, multi-tasking, multi-threading operating system
a full-featured UNIX-type operating system
a powerful, flexible, 32-bit OS
a 32-bit multi-user, multi-tasking clone of UNIX
a full-fledged UNIX-like operating system
a UNIX-type 32-bit operating system
an embedded operating system
the open-source operating system
a full, rich, dependable workhorse
the best Windows file server
a bedroom hacker's dream
the OS to run
the only real OS
the future's universal operating system
a significant OS in corporate IS departments
the #1 OS in Germany
the #1 UNIX on x86
the heir to UNIX
the largest collaborative programming effort ever
the new king of the hill
the most dynamic, interesting and exciting development on the operating system scene today
not just for geeks anymore
a lesson in hard work and well-earned rewards
the first major evolution in operating systems since MS-DOS
Doc Searls is Senior Editor of Linux Journal
Practical books for the most technical people on the planet. Newly available books include:
- Agile Product Development by Ted Schmidt
- Improve Business Processes with an Enterprise Job Scheduler by Mike Diehl
- Finding Your Way: Mapping Your Network to Improve Manageability by Bill Childers
- DIY Commerce Site by Reven Lerner
Plus many more.
- diff -u: What's New in Kernel Development
- Server Hardening
- What's New in 3D Printing, Part III: the Software
- Giving Silos Their Due
- 22 Years of Linux Journal on One DVD - Now Available
- Controversy at the Linux Foundation
- Don't Burn Your Android Yet
- Firefox OS
- February 2016 Issue of Linux Journal